[Math] In how many ways can an animal trainer arrange 5 lions and 4 tigers in a row so that no two lions are together

combinatoricspermutations

Problem :

In how many ways can an animal trainer arrange 5 lions and 4 tigers in a row
so that no two lions are together?

1st Approach :

L T L T L T L T L

The 5 lions should be arranged in the 5 places marked 'L'

This can be done in 5! ways.

The 4 tigers should be in the 4 places marked 'T'

This can be done in 4! ways.

Therefore, the lions and the tigers can be arranged in 5! $\times$ 4! ways = 2880 ways.

2nd Approach :

But I want to approach in the following way :

Let all the lions appear together so that 4L = 1unit

So, there are 4 tigers + 1 Lion = 5 units

5 things can be arranged in $5!$ ways and 5 lions can be arranged themselves in 5! ways , So there are 5! $\times 5!$ ways.

Total number of ways in which we can arrange 9 items = 9! ways.

Therefore condition when no two lions never appear together

= 9! – $5! \times 5!$ = 5!( 9.8.7.6 – 5.4.3.2) = 348480

But this wrong. Please suggest thanks…

Best Answer

you have subtracted the cases where all the lions are together but you have to substract the case where 2 or 3 or 4 lions are together!!