[Tex/LaTex] Tree, then arrow, then tree

diagramsforesttrees

I'm trying to show a transition between two trees. Right now I'm using minipages, but the spacing is all off:

The trees should be closer, and ideally the arrow should be longer. Finally, for extra bonus points, I would like the circle outlines and lines associated with the red nodes to be red as well if possible, but that's not absolutely necessary.

Here's another place where I'm trying to do it, and it won't even fit on the page. I want to scale it down to where it will, and get the spacing right. The tree on the second row should be at the end of the first row:

Here's a MWE:

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{forest, color}
\begin{document}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.32\hsize}\flushright
  \begin{forest}
    for tree={edge=->}
    [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
      [{\color{red}$\times$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{\color{red}$C_0$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
        [{\color{red}$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
      ]
      [{$\log$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
          [{$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
          [{$C_1$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
        ]
      ]
    ]
  \end{forest}
\end{minipage}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.32\hsize}\centering
  $$\longrightarrow$$
\end{minipage}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.32\hsize}\centering
  \begin{forest}
    for tree={edge=->}
    [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
      [{\color{red}$\sin$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{\color{red}$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
      ]
      [{$\log$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
          [{$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
          [{$C_1$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
        ]
      ]
    ]
  \end{forest}
\end{minipage}

\begin{minipage}[c]{0.2\hsize}\centering
  \begin{forest}
    for tree={edge=->}
    [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
      [{\color{red}$\times$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{\color{red}$C_0$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
        [{\color{red}$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
      ]
      [{$C_1$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
    ]
    ]
  \end{forest}
\end{minipage}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.2\hsize}\centering
  \begin{forest}
    for tree={edge=->}
    [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
      [{\color{red}$\sin$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{\color{red}$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
      ]
      [{$C_1$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
    ]
  \end{forest}
\end{minipage}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.2\hsize}\centering
  $$\longrightarrow$$
\end{minipage}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.2\hsize}\centering
  \begin{forest}
    for tree={edge=->}
    [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
      [{\color{red}$\sin$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{\color{red}$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
      ]
      [{$C_1$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
    ]
    ]
  \end{forest}
\end{minipage}
\begin{minipage}[c]{0.2\hsize}\centering
  \begin{forest}
    for tree={edge=->}
    [{$+$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
      [{\color{red}$\times$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered
        [{\color{red}$C_0$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
        [{\color{red}$x$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
      ]
      [{$C_1$}, circle, draw, text width=1em, text centered]
    ]
    ]

  \end{forest}
\end{minipage}
\end{document}

And here's what it compiles to. Note that the 4-tree diagram works better here because the margins are wider, but for my poster I need to be able to scale the diagram down since it won't fit in the column at that size:

Best Answer

It is most unwise to next tikzpicture environments. Since a forest environment is simply a wrapper for a tikzpicture, it is therefore most unwise to put forest environments inside \node{} within tikzpictures.

It is, however, possible to put everything within a single forest environment.

First, though, a variation on Bordaigorl's alternative solution, which just tidies up the style a bit and automatises things a bit more.

This changes the circles style to add the $...$ wrapper automatically, together with a \strut for more even circle sizes, and automatically sets the width of each node to be sufficiently large to accommodate the widest node in the tree. This avoids needing to fiddle with the value of text width to get the sizing right.

I've also specified the mid anchor so that nodes are aligned on the baseline, which is probably what you want.

I then define a new style, colour me=<colour> which colours all node borders, contents and edges in the specified colour for the current node's sub-tree. This means that unless you later change the colouring, the current node and all its descendants will be coloured in the specified way.

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{forest}
% Code  from Bordaigorl's answer at https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/320421/, based on Alan Munn's answer at https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/320316/, based on René G's question at https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/320312/
\begin{document}
\forestset{%
  declare dimen register=circles width,
  circles width'=0pt,
  circles/.style={%
    for tree={%
      circle,
      draw,
      text centered,
      edge=->,
      anchor=mid,
      delay={%
        content/.wrap value=\strut$##1$,
      }
    },
    before typesetting nodes={%
      circles width/.max={width("\foresteoption{content}")}{tree},
      delay={%
        for tree={%
          text width/.register=circles width,
        },
      },
    },
  },
  colour me/.style={%
    for tree={%
      +edge=#1,
      text=#1,
      draw=#1,
    },
  },
}
%
\scalebox{.5}{%
\begin{forest}
  circles
  [+
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [\log
      [+
        [x]
        [C_1]
      ]
    ]
  ]
\end{forest}
%
\raisebox{2cm}{$\longrightarrow$\quad}
%
\begin{forest}
  circles
  [+
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [\log
      [+
        [x]
        [C_1]
      ]
    ]
  ]
\end{forest}%
}
\end{document}

Getting a bit more complex, we can include both trees inside a single forest environment by using a phantom root.

To avoid complications with the phantom, we adjust the changes made to the content of nodes by circles:

  delay={%
    if={strequal(content(),"")&&(level()==0)}{}{%
      content/.wrap value=\strut$##1$,
    }
  }

This won't change anything if the root has content, but if the root has no content, it won't try to alter it.

We can then write our trees as follows

\begin{forest}
  circles
  [, phantom, for children={fit=band}
    [+
      [\times, colour me=red
        [C_0]
        [x]
      ]
      [\log
        [+
          [x]
          [C_1]
        ]
      ]
    ]
% \raisebox{2cm}{$\longrightarrow$\quad}
    [+
      [\sin, colour me=red
        [x]
      ]
      [\log
        [+
          [x]
          [C_1]
        ]
      ]
    ]
  ]
\end{forest}

Obviously we need to put the arrow back in. We can use the calc and fit TikZ libraries to good effect here, modifying our phantom root node a bit:

  [, phantom, for children={fit=band}, s sep+=5mm,
    before drawing tree={%
      tikz+={%
        \node (a) [inner sep=0pt, fit=(!1) (!1L) (!1F)] {};
        \node (b) [inner sep=0pt, fit=(!l) (!lL) (!lF)] {};
        \node [anchor=center] at ($(a.east)!1/2!(b.west)$) {$\longrightarrow\quad$};
      },
    },

to produce

which is better. However, it is a bit of a pain to have to do it this way.

It would be nicer if we didn't need to specify the phantom root explicitly and if we could just add the arrow by specifying say, the node the arrow should be drawn from (or to).

We'll deal with the arrows first by adding the following to \forestset:

  declare boolean={made room}{0},
  arrow to/.style={%
    for parent={%
      if made room={}{%
        for children={fit=band},
        s sep+=5mm,
        made room,
      },
    },
    before drawing tree={%
      tikz+={%
        \node (a) [inner sep=0pt, fit=() (!L) (!F)] {};
        \node (b) [inner sep=0pt, fit=(!#1) (!#1L) (!#1F)] {};
        \node [anchor=center] at ($(a.east)!1/2!(b.west)$) {$\longrightarrow\quad$};
      },
    },
  },
  arrow to/.default=n,

This allows us to specify our phantom root simply with

  [, phantom

and we can create the arrow by adding our style to the first child

    [+, arrow to

This will use n by default, for the next child. If we wanted something else, we could specify it. (I'm not sure what else would make sense, but who knows?)

If you need arrows in the other direction, obviously you could add an arrow from style along similar lines.

We add

  arrow symbol/.store in=\myarrowsymbol,
  arrow symbol=\longrightarrow,

so that we can use myarrowsymbol in the node rather than hard-coding \longrightarrow\quad. We can then add

, arrow symbol=\longrightarrow\quad

to the first child to add the spacing adjustment relevant for this particular case.

Doing away with the need to specifying the phantom root is a bit more involved. The easiest approach is probably to use the environ package to define a new environment as follows.

\environbodyname\circlestreebody
\bracketset{action character=@}
\NewEnviron{circlestree}{%
  \forest
  circles
  [, phantom @\circlestreebody]
  \endforest
}

We can then write our tree simply as

\begin{circlestree}
  [+, arrow to, arrow symbol=\longrightarrow\quad
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [\log
      [+
        [x]
        [C_1]
      ]
    ]
  ]
  [+
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [\log
      [+
        [x]
        [C_1]
      ]
    ]
  ]
\end{circlestree}

to produce the output shown above.

The 4 tree case then becomes

\begin{circlestree}
  [+
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
  [+, arrow to
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
  [+
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
  [+
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
\end{circlestree}

and produces

I'm not sure what spacing you want, but you can tweak the s sep+ as you wish, of course.

Complete code:

\documentclass[border=10pt,multi,tikz]{standalone}
\usepackage{forest}
\usetikzlibrary{calc,fit}
\environbodyname\circlestreebody
\bracketset{action character=@}
\NewEnviron{circlestree}{%
  \forest
  circles
  [, phantom @\circlestreebody]
  \endforest
}
% Code  from Bordaigorl's answer at https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/320421/, based on Alan Munn's answer at https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/320316/, based on René G's question at https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/320312/
\begin{document}
\forestset{%
  declare dimen register=circles width,
  circles width'=0pt,
  declare boolean={made room}{0},
  circles/.style={%
    for tree={%
      circle,
      draw,
      text centered,
      edge=->,
      anchor=mid,
      delay={%
        if={strequal(content(),"")&&(level()==0)}{}{%
          content/.wrap value=\strut$##1$,
        }
      }
    },
    before typesetting nodes={%
      circles width/.max={width("\foresteoption{content}")}{tree},
      delay={%
        for tree={%
          text width/.register=circles width,
        },
      },
    },
  },
  colour me/.style={%
    for tree={%
      +edge=#1,
      text=#1,
      draw=#1,
    },
  },
  arrow to/.style={%
    for parent={%
      if made room={}{%
        for children={fit=band},
        s sep+=5mm,
        made room,
      },
    },
    before drawing tree={%
      tikz+={%
        \node (a) [inner sep=0pt, fit=() (!L) (!F)] {};
        \node (b) [inner sep=0pt, fit=(!#1) (!#1L) (!#1F)] {};
        \node [anchor=center] at ($(a.east)!1/2!(b.west)$) {$\myarrowsymbol$};
      },
    },
  },
  arrow to/.default=n,
  arrow symbol/.store in=\myarrowsymbol,
  arrow symbol=\longrightarrow,
}

\begin{circlestree}
  [+, arrow to, arrow symbol=\longrightarrow\quad
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [\log
      [+
        [x]
        [C_1]
      ]
    ]
  ]
  [+
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [\log
      [+
        [x]
        [C_1]
      ]
    ]
  ]
\end{circlestree}

\begin{circlestree}
  [+
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
  [+, arrow to
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
  [+
    [\sin, colour me=red
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
  [+
    [\times, colour me=red
      [C_0]
      [x]
    ]
    [C_1]
  ]
\end{circlestree}
\end{document}

Related Solutions

[Tex/LaTex] TikZ-tree: edge-alignment in horizontal org-chart

Here's something like the second option (the node does exist).

There are only two changes to your MWE, in attribute/,style:

The xshift needs adjusting
The anchor point you need can be expressed as an angle

Sorry: I pass on the bonus.

Here it is -- I leave final adjustments to your taste:

\documentclass[12pt,a4paper]{article}
\usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
\usepackage{tikz}
\usetikzlibrary{trees}
\tikzstyle{every node}=[draw=black,thick,anchor=west, minimum height=2.5em]

\begin{document}

\begin{figure}[!htb]
\resizebox{\linewidth}{!}{

\begin{tikzpicture}[
criteria/.style={text centered, text width=2cm, fill=gray!50},
attribute/.style={%
    grow=down, xshift=0cm,
    text centered, text width=2cm,
    edge from parent path={(\tikzparentnode.225) |- (\tikzchildnode.west)}},
first/.style    ={level distance=8ex},
second/.style   ={level distance=16ex},
third/.style    ={level distance=24ex},
fourth/.style   ={level distance=32ex},
fifth/.style    ={level distance=40ex},
level 1/.style={sibling distance=10em}]
    % Main Goal
    \node[anchor=south]{SuperLongTitleWithNoMeaning}
    [edge from parent fork down]

    % Criteria and Attributes
    child{node (crit1) [criteria] {Criteria1}
        child[attribute,first]  {node {Attribute\\Number1}}
        child[attribute,second] {node {Attribute2}}
        child[attribute,third]  {node {Attribute3}}
        child[attribute,fourth] {node {Attribute4}}
        child[attribute,fifth]  {node {Another\\Attribute}}}
    %
    child{node [criteria] {Criteria2}
        child[attribute,first]  {node {Attribute1}}
        child[attribute,second] {node {Attribute2}}
        child[attribute,third]  {node {Third\\Criteria}}
        child[attribute,fourth] {node {Longtext-\\criteria}}}
    %
    child{node [criteria] {Criteria3}
        child[attribute,first]  {node {Attribute\\two lines}}
        child[attribute,second] {node {Attribute2}}     
        child[attribute,third]  {node {Attribute3}}}
    %
    child{node [criteria] {Criteria4}
        child[attribute,first]  {node {Attribute1}}
        child[attribute,second] {node {Attribute2}}}
    %
    child{node [criteria] {Criteria5}
        child[attribute,first]  {node {First\\Attribute}}
        child[attribute,second] {node {Attribute2}}
        child[attribute,third]  {node {Third\\Criteria}}
        child[attribute,fourth] {node {Longtext-\\criteria}}};
\end{tikzpicture}}
\caption{This is a nice tree.}
\end{figure}

\end{document}

[Tex/LaTex] Draw randomized tree in TikZ

This is an example modified based on page 1 of the forest package documentation.

Note the default anchors of the forest package is not the center of a node, and thus there appear to be white spaces between edges. To fix this, set both parent anchor and child anchor to center, so that they can "connect" with each other. The grow key specifies the direction to which the tree should grow. Since you want it to grow upwards, grow=north would do the trick.

\documentclass[border=2pt]{standalone}

\usepackage{forest}

\begin{document}
\pgfmathsetseed{14285}
\begin{forest}
random tree/.style n args={2}{% #1=max levels, #2=max children
if={#1>0}{repeat={random(0,#2)}{append={[,random tree={#1-1}{#2}]}}}{},
  parent anchor=center, child anchor=center, grow=north},
[,random tree={4}{3}]
\end{forest}
\end{document}

enter image description here

Update: Attaching tree to another node

This is probably not the best way to attach a forest tree to another tikz node, but it's the only thing I can come up with that works.

The idea is to put the forest tree inside a node, and use node positioning commands to "attach" it to another node. The main imperfection is that you have to manually adjust the yshift and \scalebox parameters. (I've tried using inner sep=0pt and outer sep=0pt. But those screwed up the forest picture.)

\documentclass{standalone}
\usepackage{forest}

\begin{document}

\pgfmathsetseed{12987}

\begin{tikzpicture}
  \node(s)[circle,fill=red]{some node};
  \node[yshift=-5.5pt,anchor=south]at(s.north){
    \scalebox{.5}{
      \begin{forest}
        random tree/.style n args={2}{% #1=max levels, #2=max children
        if={#1>0}{repeat={random(0,#2)}{append={[,random tree={#1-1}{#2}]}}}{},
        parent anchor=center, child anchor=center, grow=north},
        [,random tree={3}{3}]
      \end{forest}
    }
  };
\end{tikzpicture}

\end{document}

enter image description here

Best Answer

Related Solutions

[Tex/LaTex] TikZ-tree: edge-alignment in horizontal org-chart

[Tex/LaTex] Draw randomized tree in TikZ

Related Question