[Tex/LaTex] Align Equations Over Multiple Tabular Rows

alignequationstables

I'm trying to set up a table with some equations in it, however I would like the equations on multiple rows to be aligned properly. So far I have

\begin{tabular}{cc}
\hline \multicolumn{1}{l}{Header 1} \\
\hline $a = \sum_j b(c)$ & $c = d$ \\
\hline \multicolumn{1}{l}{Header 2} \\
\hline $\begin{aligned}
         e&=fghij(y) \\
         klm(x)&=nop
        \end{aligned}$ &
       $\begin{aligned}
        qr&=vwxyzstu \\
        abcde&=fghij
        \end{aligned}$
\end{tabular}

which looks like

Example Table

Note how the equals signs in the top row are not aligned with the corresponding equals signs in the bottom two rows.

So my question is; is there a way to align across different rows or am I going about this completely the wrong way?

Best Answer

tabular

Balancing the horizontal space

The equal signs aren't aligned because the columns are being centered.

The horizontal center of the a = \sum_j b(c) is not the at the equal sign but somewhere around the \sum. Just as the equal sign of your second aligned environment is probably somewhere around the v.

I introduced two macros that—with a little help—take care of that:

  • \leftlap[<opt>]{<widest part>}{<actual output>}:
    • <widest part> will be \phantomed and is to set to the widest input that will be used at this (equation) column.
    • <opt>: There is some horizontal space before the aligned environment. Empirically I could find that that space equals the amount of \,, therefore it is automatically inserted. If this shouldn't happen set the optional argument to nothing (i.e. type []).
  • \rightlap{<widest part>}{<actual output>}

\newcommand*\leftlap[3][\,]{#1\hphantom{#2}\mathllap{#3}}
\newcommand*\rightlap[2]{\mathrlap{#2}\hphantom{#1}}

When the longest part appears in the sans-aligned math

Then you use the macros in the aligned environment:

\begin{tabular}{c}
 $ vwxyzstu^{long} = x $ \\
 $ \begin{aligned} \leftlap[\!]{vwxyzstu^{long}}{a} & = \rightlap{x}{b}  \\
                                                  c & = d    \end{aligned}$
\end{tabular}

Note the \! in the optional argument. This removes the aforementioned horizontal space that is introduced by the aligned environment. (\! expands to the same horizontal space as \, just negative.)

Output
horizontal space reloaded

One can easily see that the space between two tabular lines is smaller than between two aligned lines. This can be one of the reasons that the following solution (titled „Extra columns”) should be preferred and is a lot easier to maintain.

Code

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{mathtools}
\usepackage{xcolor} % used only to show the phantomed stuff
\renewcommand\hphantom[1]{{\color[gray]{.6}#1}} % comment out!
\setlength\fboxsep{0pt} \setlength\fboxrule{.2pt} % for the \fboxes

\newcommand*\leftlap[3][\,]{#1\hphantom{#2}\mathllap{#3}}
\newcommand*\rightlap[2]{\mathrlap{#2}\hphantom{#1}}

\begin{document}
\begin{tabular}{cc} \hline 
  \multicolumn{2}{l}{Header 1} \\ \hline
  \fbox{$\leftlap{klm(x)}{a} = \rightlap{fghij(y)}{\sum_j b(c)} $}  & $\leftlap{abcde}{c} = \rightlap{vwxyzstu}{d} $ \\ \hline
  \multicolumn{2}{l}{Header 2} \\ \hline 
  \fbox{$\begin{aligned} e & = fghij(y) \\
                    klm(x) & = nop        \end{aligned}$} & $ \begin{aligned} qr & = vwxyzstu \\
                                                                           abcde & = fghij      \end{aligned}$
\end{tabular}
\end{document}

Output

horizontal space

Extra columns

If you do not want the equal sign to be the default, you can use

\newcolumntype{M}{R@{$\;$}L}

instead. This introduces the right space between the left side of the equation and the = sign. The right part of the equation can then started as always, e.g. & = \sum_j.

Code

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath,array}
\newcolumntype{R}{>{$}r<{$}}
\newcolumntype{L}{>{$}l<{$}}
\newcolumntype{M}{R@{${}={}$}L}
\begin{document}
\begin{tabular}{MM}\hline
    \multicolumn{4}{l}{Header 1}            \\ \hline
    a      & \sum_j b(c) & c     & d        \\ \hline
    \multicolumn{4}{l}{Header 2}            \\ \hline
    e      & fghij(y)    & qr    & vwxyzstu \\
    klm(x) & nop         & abcde & fghij    \\
\end{tabular}
\end{document}

Output

Output tabular

alignat

Another approach would be the direct use of one of amsmaths *align* environments.

The next step (if the \hlines are needed) would be a TikZ \matrix solution but I guess this would go a little bit too far.

Code

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
\begin{document}
\begin{alignat*}{2}
    \rlap{Header 1} \hphantom{klm(x)} &                          &                          &            \\
                                    a & = \textstyle \sum_j b(c) &                        c & = d        \\
    \rlap{Header 2} \hphantom{klm(x)} &                          &                          &            \\
                                    e & = fghij(y)               &                       qr & = vwxyzstu \\
                               klm(x) & = nop                    & \hspace{\columnsep}abcde & = fghij    \\
\end{alignat*}
\end{document}

Output

Output alignat

Related Question