Perpetual Motion – Would a Pendulum Swing Indefinitely in a Frictionless Vacuum? Exploring Newtonian Mechanics and Energy Conservation

dissipationenergy-conservationfrictionnewtonian-mechanicsperpetual-motion

I am attempting to settle a friendly bet. Would a pendulum swing indefinitely in a hypothetical vacuum (i.e. no air resistance) having a hypothetical frictionless bearing (i.e. no energy lost due to friction) assuming the following

  1. The frictionless vacuum is on Earth (9.8 m/s^2).

  2. The pendulum is already in motion and no other external forces other than gravity act on the pendulum.

Best Answer

The real world is full of small effects that only matter when you've eliminated everything else. For example, if the pendulum has a non-zero conductivity its motion through the Earth's magnetic field would cause eddy currents and dissipate energy. This would be a tiny effect, but it would mean the pendulum wouldn't oscillate for ever. I imagine the more creative minds hereabouts could come up with a number of vanishingly small effects that would eventually damp the pendulum.

If you manage to eliminate all these effects then yes, the pendulum will oscillate forever. However you're just asking whether if all sources of energy dissipation are removed will any energy be dissipated, and the answer is obviously no.

Related Question