Energy – Why is Energy Not an SI Base Unit?

energymetrologysi-units

According to a textbook I have begun to read, there are seven base SI units:

  • Length
  • Mass
  • Time
  • Temperature
  • Amount of a substance
  • Electric current
  • Luminous intensity

What I do not understand is, why have these been chosen as the fundamental units? It seems to me that mass, amount, current and luminous intensity could all be expressed with energy. Instead energy is for some reason a derived unit. Why is this?

Best Answer

  • Temperature
  • Amount of a substance
  • Luminous intensity

are pretty much bogus fundamental units. The unit temperature is just an expression of the Boltzmann constant (or you could say the converse, that the Boltzmann constant is not fundamental as it is merely an expression of the anthropocentric and arbitrary unit temperature).

The unit energy will be whatever is the unit of force times the unit of length. AJoule is the same as a Newton-Meter, which are already defined in the SI system.

You should read the NIST page on units to get the low-down on it.

In my opinion, electric charge is a more fundamental physical quantity than electric current, but NIST (or more accurately, BIPM) defined the unit current first and then, using the unit current and unit time, they defined the unit charge. I would have sorta defined charge first and then current.

Just like the unit charge (or current) is just another way to express the vacuum permittivity or, alternatively the Coulomb constant and the unit temperature is just another way to express the Boltzmann constant, the unit time, unit length, and unit mass, all three taken together could be just another way to express the speed of light, the Planck constant, and the gravitational constant. But because $G$ is not easy to measure (given independent units of measure) and can never be measured as accurately as we can measure the frequency of "radiation corresponding to the transition between the two hyperfine levels of the ground state of the caesium 133 atom", we will never have $G$ as a defined constant as we do for $c$ and as we will soon for $\hbar$ and perhaps for $\epsilon_0$ and $k_\text{B}$.

But once we define length, time, and mass independently, we cannot define energy independently. The Joule is a "derived unit".

EDIT: so i will try to explain why the candela is bogus. (i had already for the mol.) so there is a sorta arbitrary specification of frequency, then what is the difference between 1 Candela and $\frac{4 \pi}{683} \approx$ 0.0184 watts? bogus base unit.