Electric Circuits – Why Current Doesn’t Pass Through a Resistance When There’s a Path Without Resistance?

electric-circuitselectric-currentelectrical-resistanceshort-circuits

Why doesn't current pass through a resistance if there is another path without resistance? How does it know there is resistance on that path?

Some clarification:

  1. I understand that some current will flow through the resistance.
  2. A depiction of this phenomenon through Ohm's laws does not answer the 'why' part of the question as it does not illuminate the process behind this phenomenon.
  3. There seems to be disagreement among the answers on whether the charge repulsions are enough to cause this effect. Cited research would be appreciated to resolve this issue.
  4. To refine what I mean by this question, I think I should give an example of why I am curious as to the causal background of this phenomenon. If charge repulsions do in fact repel 'current' in the example of the short circuit, then why does the same phenomenon not happen in other parallel circuits. (Again, I know that not all circuits behave ideally)
  5. I believe the question is expressed in the most straightforward way possible. This should, however, not affect the scope of the answers. I do not wish to see or think on the level of an electron as circuit behavior always includes a cumulative effect due to the nature of electrostatic interactions.

Best Answer

The basic circuit theory "rules" you imply, are high level simplifications applicable at a large scale and at slow speeds.

If you look at it close and fast enough, you could say that a current really starts to go into the obstructed path, but the electric field in front of the obstruction would build up gradually and current will start to repartition into the free path where it can start to flow. Naively you could say that the electric field will "sniff out" the paths. Actually in reality the current will also bounce off the obstructions, reflect and go back and forth etc. This is a real mess in practical electrical engineering at high frequencies.