[Physics] Why does transition from one electron shell to another shell always produce massless photon

atomic-physicsorbitalsquantum mechanics

When electrons transition from a higher energy state to a lower energy state (energy difference $E$), they produce massless photon with frequency $\nu$ where

$ \Delta E= h \nu$

(h is Planck constant). We know energy-mas relation $ E=mc^2$. Why not create some kind particle, in this case a particle that has mass m that we could calculate from the energy difference of the two states of the electron? Is there any kind critical energy difference $\Delta E_c$ such that lower than $\Delta E_c$ always is creating photon and higher than $\Delta E_c$ its value create particle with mass?

Best Answer

There are a few reasons why the particle produced needs to be a photon. Aside from conserving energy, we also need to conserve momentum, charge and spin, for example. So you would need to ask what other particle, instead of a photon, could be emitted while satisfying all those conservation requirements.

If you just consider energy and spin conservation, the total amount of energy available in electron transitions in an atom is small, and not enough to make any of the other massive Bosons. To use your terminology, the maximum energy difference in electron transitions, Δ𝐸, is way below the energy Δ𝐸𝑐 you would need to create any of the other known massive particles that satisfy the other conservation requirements.

Related Question