Material Science – Why Does Diamond Have Lower Tensile Strength Than Iron?

constrained-dynamicsmaterial-sciencestructural-beam

Let me first give you the tensile strength of both substances:

Diamond:  1600 MPa
Steel  :  2617 MPa

As you guys should know, tensile strength is how much a material can be stressed or pulled before it breaks. The data above shows that diamond is more brittle than steel. But, I thought a diamond is the strongest natural object in this planet. How can it be more brittle than something which is man-made? Don't the 4 strong covalent bonds in between the carbon atoms resist the pull and carry through huge amount of weight?

Best Answer

Strength of materials is affected by defects. A perfect crystal of iron would be extremely strong. Once a crack starts, it is not so hard to make it advance one atom deeper. Think of tearing open a plastic bag. Much easier once the tear starts.

Brittle materials can be easier to break because they stretch less. It is easier to tear a sheet of paper than a sheet of rubber. Rubber stretches so the force is distributed through a large region. In paper, it is all at a small region near the tip of the tear. A small region has a smaller cross sectional area. The stress is larger for the same force.

Related Question