[Physics] Why does a wine glass with less water resonate at a higher frequency

resonance

In this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWwM7F-zaHs, Professor Lewin showed that for the tube, the less water there is, the longer the effective length of the tube and therefore, the lower the frequency.

He then demonstrates an opposite effect for a wine glass. Namely, an empty wine glass resonates at a higher frequency than a filled one. Why is that so?

Best Answer

For the pipe, it is the air that is vibrating. When the column of air is shorter the frequency is higher.

In the case of the wine glass, the glass (not the air) is vibrating. Add water and you increase the inertia of the glass, which lowers the frequency of the resonance. The air may also resonate - but for something the size of a wine glass the frequency is very high - inaudible compared to the vibration of the glass.