[Physics] Why do we have to dump the extra entropy created in a heat engine

entropyheat-enginethermodynamicswork

In his introduction to thermophysics, Daniel Schroeder writes the following about the process in a heat engine:

Only part of the energy absorbed as heat can be converted to work. The reason is, that the heat, as it flows in, brings along entropy, which must somehow be disposed of before the cycle can start over. To get rid of the entropy, every heat engine must dump some waste heat into its environment.

Why must the extra entropy be disposed?

In my understanding, we could gather more and more extra entropy, while converting all the heat into work until the entropy reaches its maximum. Then a state of equilibrium would be reached and no more energy could be withdrawn from the system according to the second law of thermodynamics. But then we could just go to the next machine and do the same, always converting all heat into work.

Best Answer

We are talking about cycles here. After a complete cycle the system must be right back where it started. Since entropy is a state variable, it must then be that after one complete cycle the entropy is at its "initial" value. By the second law this must mean that the entropy has to "go somewhere else". If you "gathered more and more" entropy, then it is no longer a cycle.

If you did want to do what you propose of replacing engines then it would be extremely inefficient. You would get one "run" out of the process and then have to get a new engine (I am not sure how this would actually work). It is much better to use the same engine on a cycle.

Related Question