[Physics] Why do heavier isotopes of the same element have smaller atomic radii than lighter isotopes of the same element

atomic-physicselectronsisotopesorbitalsquantum mechanics

I have been trying to figure out why higher-mass isotopes have higher melting and boiling points than lower-mass isotopes of the same element.

A Quora answer on this topic explored the idea that electron orbits in atoms with smaller nuclei behave as if the electron is lighter, contributing to larger orbits, whereas atoms with larger nuclei behave as if the electron is heavier, contributing to smaller orbits.

Could someone explain why the size of the nucleus affects electron orbits?

Best Answer

Hints:

  1. Heavier isotopes have higher reduced mass $\mu$.

  2. For a hydrogen-like atom, the energy levels $E$ are proportional (& the radius $r$ is inversely proportional) to the reduced mass $\mu$.

  3. More generally, it can be deduced from dimensional analysis alone that the conclusions of pt. 2 hold for any spinless non-relativistic multi-electron atom governed by the Schrödinger equation: $$r~~\propto~~\frac{\hbar^2}{\mu ~k_e e^2}~~\propto~~\frac{1}{\mu}\qquad\text{and}\qquad E~~\propto~~\mu\frac{ (k_e e^2)^2}{\hbar^2}~~\propto~~\mu.$$ This is because that that model has only 3 dimensionful constants: