[Physics] Which force is doing the work here

forcesnewtonian-mechanicswork

My text book (Fundamentals of Physics by Halliday, Resnick, and Walker) mentions the following about the work done in internal energy transfers:

An initially stationary ice-skater pushes away from a railing and then slides over the ice. Her kinetic energy increases because of an external force F on her from the rail. However, that force does not transfer energy from the rail to her. Thus, the force does no work on her. Rather, her kinetic energy increases as a result of internal transfers from the biochemical energy in her muscles.

This is confusing me a lot. The energy transfer is clearly internal but work must be done by the force as work done is defined as the (dot) product of force and displacement and the definition makes no reference to any transfer of energy.

I thought work done by a force just means that the force is causing a transfer of energy to (or from) an object, and gives no information about whether the energy is coming from the object exerting the force.

My confusion is not over whether work is being done or not but which force is doing the work which ends up causing the change in kinetic energy.

Best Answer

Let's make a simple example. A block with a compressed spring attached to it is on a frictionless horizontal surface against a stationary, immovable wall. The spring is released, and the block is then pushed away from the wall, thus gaining kinetic energy.

The relevant forces here are 1) the force between the spring and the block and 2) the force between the spring and the wall. Which force does work here? Force 1 did, because it is applied over a distance. The energy is transferred from the potential energy stored in the spring to the kinetic energy of the block.

In your example, the skater is the block, and the arms/muscles are the spring.