Newtonian Mechanics – Understanding Which String Breaks When Pulling a Hanging Block

experimental-physicsforcesnewtonian-mechanics

Intro:

In completing Walter Lewin's 6th lecture on Newton's Laws, he presents an experiment (go to 42:44) which leaves me baffled.


Experiment:

(I recommend watching the video; see link above.)

  • There is a $2$ kg block with 2 identical strings attached to it: one at the top, the other at the bottom.
  • The top string is attached to a "ceiling", and the bottom to a "floor".
  • Professor Lewin "stretches" the system (by pulling on the bottom string) with the block not accelerating.
  • One string snaps.

Prediction:

  • Initially, the top string has a tension of approximately $20$ N, to counter the force of gravity. The bottom string has no tension at all.
  • Then, when Lewin pulls the bottom string, it gains some tension $n$ N. To counter act the force exerted by the bottom string, the top string exerts now $20 + n$ N.
  • I assume that the string with more force will give out sooner, leading me to conclude that the top string will break.

Results:

(This was conducted by Lewin, not me; see link above.)

  • Trial 1: Bottom string breaks.
  • Trial 2: Top string breaks.
  • Trial 3: Bottom string breaks.

Additional Notes:

The results don't seem consistent. If I was right, I'd expect all 3 experiments to be right; conversely, if I was wrong, I'd expect all 3 experiments wrong, with one exception: the results are more-less random and one result isn't preferred over the other.


Question:

  • Why was my prediction incorrect?
  • Was there a flaw in my logic?
  • Why were the results inconsistent?

Best Answer

While I haven't seen the video, the description matches an old science trick using inertia: if you want the top string to snap, pull slowly. To snap the bottom string, pull suddenly - the inertia of the weight will “protect" the upper string for a brief moment.

Related Question