[Physics] Spherical charge in two different dielectric materials

dielectricelectric-fieldssymmetry

I am trying to freshen up my memory about electrical fields and I came across this exercise from school.

A sphere with a constantly distributed charge is located in between two different dielectrics (see picture at the bottom) and the task is to calculate the electrical field. I have a sample solution that makes the following assumptions:

  1. The electrical field at the boundary between the two dielectrics has to be constant. (I understand this)
  2. The electrical field has only a radial component. (I accept this as well)
  3. The electrical field has spherical symmetry i.e. it has the same magnitude regardless if it is in the upper or lower dielectric. I am sort of stumbling over this assumption, because I feel that the setup is not symmetric.

So, how come the electrical field is radial symmetric? This doesn't seem intuitive to me. Or is the sample solution incorrect.

enter image description here

EDIT: Okay, I think I figured it out. The sphere is actually a conducting sphere. Now since the whole sphere has the same potential and lets assume that at infinity the potential is zero. The static electrical field has to be symmetrical around the sphere, since the integral from infinity over the electrical field onto the sphere has to be consistent from all directions. This also means, that the charges inside the sphere will shift accordingly. Can somebody confirm this?

Best Answer

The total charge density, which is the sum of free charge density and bound charge density is constant all over the sphere, but the free and bound charge densities differ for upper and lower half of the sphere.

Your question about symmetry of total charge density can be answered easily, assuming that you know the symmetry of electric field. (your reasoning for it's spherical symmetry is correct):

($E_1$ means electric field in the first region and $E_2$ the field of the second region)

$$\mathbf{E}_1=\mathbf{E}_2 =\mathbf{E}_{out} \tag{as you stated}$$ $$\mathbf{E}_{out} . \hat r-\mathbf{E}_{in}.\hat r=\frac{\sigma}{\epsilon}_0 \,\,\,,\,\,\,\mathbf{E}_{in}=0 \to \sigma={\epsilon}_0 \mathbf{E}_{out} . \hat r$$

You can arrive at this result by calculating free and bound charge densities directly by solving for potential using Laplace equation too:

The problem is clearly azimuthal symmetric, and also according to your argument, it isn't a function of $\theta$ neither; i.e., the problem is 1-D and $V$ is a function of $r$.

Using the fact that potential is continuous at the boundary of the two regions and also vanishes at $\infty$, the only remaining term of the potential expansion in spherical coordinates will be:

$$V=\frac{Cq}{r}$$ $$ \mathbf{D}=-\epsilon \nabla V \to \cases{\mathbf{D}_1=\frac{\epsilon_1Cq}{r^2}\hat r \\ \mathbf{D}_2=\frac{\epsilon_2Cq}{r^2}\hat r}$$

Now, assuming a spherical surface surrounding the sphere and applying Gauss law for $\mathbf{D}$, we will find $C$:

$$\oint{\mathbf{D}.d\mathbf{S}}=Q_{free}\to C=\frac{1}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)}$$

$$V=\frac{1}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{r}$$

Now we find $\mathbf{D}_1$ , $\mathbf{D}_2$ and $\mathbf{E}$ :

$$\mathbf{E}=\frac{1}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{r^2}\hat r$$

$$\mathbf{D}_1=\frac{\epsilon_1}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{r^2}\hat r$$

$$\mathbf{D}_2=\frac{\epsilon_2}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{r^2}\hat r$$

using the relation $\sigma_f=\mathbf{D}.\hat r $ we will have:

$$\to \cases{\sigma_{1f}=\frac{q\epsilon_1}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{1}{R^2} \\ \sigma_{2f}=\frac{q\epsilon_2}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{1}{R^2}}$$

From these two relations for $\sigma_{f}$s it is evident that the total free charge is equal to $q$, as expected: $$\sigma_{1f}\times 2\pi R^2+\sigma_{2f}\times 2\pi R^2=q$$

Now we find bound charge densities. First we should find polarization vectors $\mathbf{P}_1$ and $\mathbf{P}_2$:

$$\mathbf{P}=\mathbf{D}-\epsilon_0 \mathbf{E} \to \cases{\mathbf{P}_1= \frac{\epsilon_1- \epsilon_0}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{r^2}\hat r \\ \mathbf{P}_2=\frac{\epsilon_2- \epsilon_0}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{r^2}\hat r }$$ and

$$\sigma_b =\mathbf{P}.\hat r\to \cases{\sigma_{b1}=-\frac{\epsilon_1- \epsilon_0}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{R^2} \\ \sigma_{b2}=-\frac{\epsilon_2- \epsilon_0}{2\pi (\epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2)} \frac{q}{R^2} }$$

Now you can see that on each half sphere the sum of bound and free charge densities is equal, as expected: $$\sigma_{b1}+\sigma_{f1}=\sigma_{b2}+\sigma_{f2}$$

Related Question