[Physics] Questions on the movie Gravity (2013)

angular momentumnewtonian-mechanicsorbital-motionsatellites

To start off, I'm not a physicist but a programmer, and only had a few years of physics education in high school so I'm sorry if I'm asking a stupid question.

I just finished watching the movie Gravity (2013) and I found online already a whole list of things wrong with the movie, but there are two things that I think is wrong that I couldn't find:

  • The premise of the movie is that a satellite is hit by a missle which causes debris setting off a chain reaction leading to the catastrophic destruction of space stations and space shuttles. Is it true that debris can stay in orbit at the same height as space stations, while having a very large relative speed to the space stations? It was my understanding that if the velocity of objects change, then also its orbit altitude (given a circular orbit), right?
  • In the end, the main character gets to the Chinese space station, which is already deorbiting although it seems structurally intact. Is it possible for the intact station to deorbit, simply by getting a little bit hit (it couldn't have been much since it was still mostly intact)?

Best Answer

  • The satellite did not start in the ISS orbit, and not all orbits are circles.

The ISS orbit is free of large satellites. So the fictional one from the movie was in a different orbit. Therefore it's not too difficult to believe that debris from it would have a high relative velocity. The debris might have been in a very elliptical orbit with a large range of altitudes.

It's not even necessary for them to have different altitudes. As long as they intersect at an angle, the relative speeds will be very high. (Much higher than would be useful for a movie).

That doesn't mean that the action depicted in the movie was accurate, just that any intersection would likely be at very high closing speeds.

  • By large objects, no.

If the other space station had been hit by debris, it would have been damaged. High-speed impacts can't change the momentum of the entire station much. The material gives way before forces build up much, and the interaction time is low.

Deorbit happens over a much longer period of time due primarily to atmospheric drag.

Related Question