Vacuum Physics – Feasibility of an Impossible Vacuum Balloon

vacuum

As it is well known, a vacuum balloon using the materials we have at our disposal is not possible, because of the sheer force they have to resist from the air outside.

I have an idea and I want to know if there is anything that makes it impossible.

1) Build a balloon out of graphene which is very light and it is conductive too.
2) Since graphene is not airtight, cover graphene (that is not yet inflated) with a good electrical insulator which is also airtight.
3) Now make the graphene store electric charge.
4) This would exert force from inside as the electric charges on the graphene repel each other.
5) This causes the balloon to inflate while having a vacuum inside.

Now my question is there any theoretical problems (not engineering problems) with this model?

Best Answer

First, it is not "well known, a vacuum balloon using the materials we have at our disposal is not possible, because of the sheer force they have to resist from the air outside." In our patent application (Akhmeteli, Gavrilin, Layered Shell Vacuum Balloons, you can find it at USPTO site or at http://akhmeteli.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/vacuum_balloons_cip.pdf ), we show that sandwich structures made of existing materials can be both strong enough to withstand atmospheric pressure and light enough to float in air, according to our finite element analysis. As for your idea, external charge can gather on the surface of your structure due to discharge in air, say, during thunder, and ruin your design.

Related Question