[Physics] Is the triangle stronger

forcesgeometry

I have a friend who cedes that a framework that is a triangle would be stronger than a square framework. But he maintains that a square solid would not be stronger than a triangle solid. Ie a set of steel beams in a triangle is stronger than a set of steel beams in a square, but a solid square out of Steel would be stronger than a solid triangle out of Steel.

Is he correct? Why or why not?

Best Answer

A parallelogram defined by its perimeter is unstable to shear. If the top corner is pushed it will scissor shut. A triangle defined by its perimeter is rigid toward shear. Solid planes cannot scissor shut. However, eccentricity of an axial force results in a bending moment acting on beam elements - buckling. Pattern the surface to resist other failure modes.

Related Question