Special Relativity – How to Understand Speed of Light Invariance Through Different Mediums and Time Dilation Effects

inertial-framesinvariantsrefractionspecial-relativityspeed-of-light

So, we know the speed of light through a vacuum is $c$.

Let us say that both our observers are moving past each other at speed $v$ in a medium in which the speed of light is $c'$.

  1. So, does the usual postulate of relativity apply in this case as well? That is, will the speed of a light beam in that medium be $c'$ in the frame of both the observers irrespective of the speed of source/speed of observer, etc.?

  2. Will all the relativistic phenomena like length contraction, time dilation, twin paradox etc. apply in this case as well?
    If yes, then will the formula for $\gamma$ be modified to use $c'$, or should we still use $c$ to calculate $\gamma$?

Best Answer

The short answer to the first question is no. The point is to understand that light does not have to be given the special pedestal we give it while analysing problems such as above. Anything moving at a speed $c$, be it a photon or any other particle would follow the second postulate of relativity. On the other hand photons which don't travel at $c$ due to being in a medium are just normal particles whose velocities have to be added by relativity-

$$v_x'=\dfrac{v_x-v}{1-vv_x/c^2}$$

The answer to the second problem is yes, they will apply exactly the same way. The second postulate of the special theory says that anything moving at $299,792,458$ m/s moves at that speed irrespective of how you move. The lorentz transformations are normally derived for photons, but any particle moving with a speed $c$ would be enough, since the postulate is about the speed of light, not light itself.

The formula for $\gamma$ = $1/\sqrt{1-v^2/c^2}$ to be used in time dilation / length contraction will still use c and not c'

Related Question