Special Relativity – Is Light Faster Than Current Measurements Suggest? Understanding Speed of Light in Cosmology

cosmologyexperimental-physicsrefractionspecial-relativityspeed-of-light

It is well established that the light speed in a perfect vacuum is roughly $3\times 10^8 \:\rm m/s$. But it is also known that outer space is not a perfect vacuum, but a hard vacuum. So, is the speed limit theoretically faster than what we can measure empirically, because the hard vacuum slows the light down? Is this considered when measuring distances with light?

Best Answer

If we take air, then the refractive index at one atmosphere is around $1.0003$. So if we measure the speed of light in air we get a speed a factor of about $1.0003$ too slow i.e. a fractional error $\Delta c/c$ of $3 \times 10^{-4}$.

The difference of the refractive index from one, $n-1$, is proportional to the pressure. Let's write the pressure as a fraction of one atmosphere, i.e. the pressure divided by one atmosphere, then the fractional error in our measurement of $c$ is going to be about:

$$ \frac{\Delta c}{c} = 3 \times 10^{-4} \, P $$

In high vacuum labs we can, without too much effort, get to $10^{-10}$ torr and this is around $10^{-13}$ atmospheres or 10 nPa. So measuring the speed of light in this vacuum would give us an error:

$$ \frac{\Delta c}{c} \approx 3 \times 10^{-17} $$

And this is already smaller than the experimental errors in the measurement.

So while it is technically correct that we've never measured the speed of light in a perfect vacuum, the vacuum we can generate is sufficiently good that its effect on the measurement is entirely negligible.