[Physics] Is it safe to apply Kirchhoff’s voltage law to a closed loop containing an inductance with unsteady current

electric-circuitselectricityinductancevoltage

Is it safe to apply Kirchhoff's voltage law to a closed loop containing an inductance with unsteady current? If I have a circuit that is just a battery in series with a resistor and an inductor, can I apply Kirchhoff's voltage law to that loop while the current has not reached its steady state value yet?

Best Answer

Yes, Kirchhoff's voltage law (KVL):

Sum of voltage drops across all elements connected via perfect conducting wire in series in to a closed circuit is zero.

is valid for lumped element RLC circuits, so also for inductors (for currents that do not change too fast, so voltage can be measured in practice). In practical circuits designed not to radiate, voltage can be measured across any element and KVL can be validated experimentally. It is valid for common frequencies, up to hundreds of MHz and even higher to GHz range if parasitic elements are added to the model.

The whole theory of RLC circuits with harmonic voltage sources is derived from KVL being valid all the time, while currents and voltages change.

Some people say Kirchhoff's law is not valid for a circuit with an inductor, since $\oint \mathbf E \cdot d \mathbf s \neq 0$ if ideal inductor is in the circuit. However, that is actually not a problem for KVL, because KVL is formulated using voltage drops, not integrals of total electric field. Voltage drop across inductor may be non-zero, even if total electric field in the wire is zero, because the drop is defined not by integral of total electric field, but by integral of electrostatic component of that field.

Related Question