[Physics] Intro Mechanics: Finding ball speeds after collision

collisionconservation-lawsnewtonian-mechanics

So I'm reading about conservation of energy, momentum, balls colliding etc. and unsurprisingly there are hundreds of questions in my textbook where essentially they give me some of the variables (m1, v1 and M2 for example) and then tell me to find the other variable (v2) simply by using the formulas

I am fine with doing that, however what I don't understand is actually how the 2-ball-system knows how to distribute the momentum and velocity between itself. Why shouldn't all the energy and momentum in the system go to one ball, or the other ball, or be a 50:50 split, or be such that velocity is the same for both balls and so arranges itself according to the masses, or any other principle?

Best Answer

The answer is that there is no simple answer. The way that energy and momentum get split up in the aftermath of a collision depends on the details of the collision itself, and there is nothing in the conservation laws themselves that influences this.

The simplest case is in one-dimensional collisions, where both objects are constrained to move along the same line. Even in this simple system the ensuing dynamics are not completely determined, and they depend on how 'elastic' or 'inelastic' the collision is; that is, on how much kinetic energy is lost to other energetic channels. You can and should experiment with this: take carts on an air rail and make them collide with each other, both elastically (metal-on-metal should be fine, or add springs if not) and inelastically (use blue-tack to make them stick, or add e.g. a ball of paper that can be crumpled). You will find that the details of the collision affect the outcome, even for the same initial velocities.

When more dimensions are involved, the details of the collision become much more important, even for fully elastic collisions. This is again something you should experiment with, using a pool table or an air table or something similar. In general, the precise point of contact has a large influence on the collision outcome, and it is in such details that the balls 'decide' which way they're going, and how fast.