Photons – How to Understand If a Photon Takes All Possible Paths and Travels Faster Than Light?

faster-than-lightpath-integralphotonsquantum-electrodynamicsvirtual-particles

Let's assume we are in a perfect vacuum and let a photon travel from a point $A$ to a point $B$. As far as my understanding of quantum physics goes, the photon takes all possible paths between $A$ and $B$, as shown in this picture:

enter image description here

Here, I have drawn 3 possible paths $a$, $b$ and $c$. Path $a$ goes directly from $A$ to $B$ and its length is thus equal to the distance $AB$. it takes light $\frac{d(A,B)}{c}$ seconds to get from $A$ to $B$ on this path.

As you can see, the paths $b$ and $c$ are not very straight, so their length is greater than $AB$. If the photon were to travel along one of these paths, the time it would take to get from $A$ to $B$ would be equal to the length of the path $l(b)$ or $l(c)$ divided by the speed of light $c$. As for both $l(b)$ and $l(c)$ is $l \gt d(A,B)$, the photon has to travel longer along the paths $b$ and $c$ than on $a$.

However, if I understand correctly, in quantum physics, a particle such as our photon travels along all paths at once. This means that it arrives at $B$ after $\frac{d(A,B)}{c}$ seconds, but somehow also travels paths which are longer than $d(A,B)$.

How is this possible without the particle travelling faster than light (which is not possible, according to special relativity)? I know that the photon does not "split up" or something like this (which maybe was implied by my question) and I am not very familiar with quantum physics, so I am convinced that this is just a misconception of mine.

As I am still in school, I would, if possible, prefer a non-mathematical answer; possibly an answer with both the concept and the math, so that it is also useful to more advanced users.

Best Answer

To be more precise, it sounds like what you're describing is the path integral formulation of quantum mechanics. Within this framework, every possible path between $A$ and $B$ contributes a complex number to an infinite sum, which is used to calculate the "actual" path the particle takes.

It is tempting at first to ask how a particle could take a path that in theory requires it to travel faster than light, and these paths are considered in this approach and do contribute to the sum, however the classical path the particle takes never requires it to travel faster than light. The paths further from the classical path effectively cancel each other out in the infinite sum. For a nice visual representation of this see here.

Saying that the particle does traverse all paths is doing something that "pop-physics" outlets often do: assume that exactly what happens in a mathematical model also happens in real life. This is analogous to "the fabric of spacetime is bent by mass and energy", it certainly allows people to visualise what's going on but it is an analogy that can only be taken so far.