[Physics] How to calculate the velocity needed for a rocket to get to a L1 point (escape a body without orbiting)

gravityrocket-science

I'm looking to calculate parameters around launching, say, a model rocket STRAIGHT to the moon. This does not mean through orbital insertion into a stable ~17,000 MPH relative to earth's surface and then Hohmann Transfer maneuvers.

What I mean is reaching an altitude that would correspond to the Earth-Moon L1 Lagrangian Point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lagrangian_points, with a minimal amount of velocity left to fall toward the Moon. For the purposes of the calculation, this could mean getting there with zero velocity (though it would need just a slight bit more, and have to be timed perfectly with the Moon's rotation).

Sun Earth System

Tentative Values:

  1. Where is Earth-Moon L1, on average? 345,000km from Earth's center?
  2. Earth's Radius at the Equator? 6,384km?
  3. What altitude is the Earth-Moon L1? 338,616km?
  4. Without air resistance, how much energy would be required to get a given mass to this altitude? (straight up, no orbital insertion)
  5. What does the formula for this look like (getting to a specified altitude of a given astronomical body)?
  6. If you were to launch from, say, 100km up with a few weather balloons, how would the formula need to be adjusted?
  7. What type and how many rocket engines would be required to get a tiny model rocket to this altitude, regardless of feasibility?
  8. Other than the issues of landing safely, would this be a more efficient way to transport supplies to the moon if they could survive the crash landing?

Best Answer

4.Without air resistance, how much energy would be required to get a given mass to this altitude?

Energy Needed ($E$) = Potential Energy at L1 ($V_{L1}$) - Potential Energy at Earth's Surface ($V_e$)

$$V_e = -Gm(\frac{M_e}{r_e} +\frac{M_l}{LD - r_e}) $$

$$V_{L1} = -Gm(\frac{M_e}{d_{L1}} +\frac{M_l}{LD - d_{L1}}) $$

where $m$ is the transported mass, $M_e$ is Earth's mass, $M_l$ is the Moon's mass, $LD$ is the center to center Earth-Moon distance, $r_e$ is Earth's radius, and $d_{L1}$ is the distance from the center of the Earth to L1.

5.What does the formula for this look like (getting to a specified altitude of a given astronomical body)?

The formula above it for a two body system, along the center line of such a system. You could replace $d_{L1}$ with a smaller distance if you want to go less than all the way to L1 along this line.

6.If you were to launch from, say, 100km up with a few weather balloons, how would the formula need to be adjusted?

In the formula for $V_e$ substitute $r_e + 100km$ for $r_e$

7.What type and how many rocket engines would be required to get a tiny model rocket to this altitude, regardless of feasibility?

This subquestion doesn't have a specific answer. Even if a zero mass payload is assumed, the propellant and structure holding the propellant have mass. The chemical nature and mass of the propellant, mass of the inert sturcture, and arrangement of stages would be major factors. Multiple stages are advantageous to reduce the mass during flight by eliminating no longer needed inert sturcture.

8.Other than the issues of landing safely, would this be a more efficient way to transport supplies to the moon if they could survive the crash landing?

If fuel is not used to make a soft landing on the Moon, this would definitely increase efficiency.

Addtional considerations:

None of the above considers the gravitational potential of the Sun. If you don't mind crashing into the Moon, launching when the Moon is between the Earth and the Sun would minimize the amount of energy needed. This would add a third term involving the Sun's mass and distances to the Sun to each of the potential energy equations.

As previously suggested by user "I like Serena", since Earth is rotating about its own axis, a rocket launched from Earth will have an initial velocity component due to this rotation. It is optimal to launch from near the equator to take advantage of the maximum velocity due to rotation, as well as greater Earth diameter/less gravity. Launch should be timed such that the rotational velocity component is directed to the Moon as much as possible, at which time the direction of the Moon will be generally eastward.

The L1 point is calculated considering gravitational potential and centrifugal force of a body in the rotating frame. The point of maximum gravitational potential along a line joining the Earth and Moon would be a somewhat different point. It would be more correct to find the maximum gravitation potential along this line and use that potential energy value, although it should be similar to the potential energy to get to L1.

For more information on low energy transport to the moon, without using Hohmann transfer, and without crash landing, see Low Energy Transfer to the Moon. An alternative low-energy approach was used by the 1991 Japanese Hiten mission.