[Physics] How much lift does an airplane get from its wings, vs the rest of the airframe

aircraftfluid dynamicslift

Consider a big commercial airliner, like a 727, 747, or a 787.

At cruising altitude, under standard conditions, how much of the lift of the aircraft comes from the wings, and how much from the rest of the airframe — the tube that holds all the people?

My general impression from watching airplanes in flight is that the velocity vector of the centre of mass of the airplane tends not to be pointing in the same direction as the nose of the aircraft. They're usually a little off, moreso during take-off and landing but it seems like they're almost always a little off.

When I look at a side-view of a 747, I see that the angle of attack of the airfoil doesn't quite match the line of the tube part of the hull. Moreover, the tube has a pretty large surface area relative to the wing area.

enter image description here

My suspicion is that there's maybe stability reasons why you'd want the tube to not be flat in steady-state flight. And perhaps that's part of the reason why the bottom of the tube is more flat towards the front Is something like this what's going on?

enter image description here

Best Answer

Most of the lift comes from the main wing, and in fact the tail lifts down, so the main wing also has to support that. (That's for a stability reason.)

The lift of a wing is roughly proportional to two things:

  • angle of attack, and
  • airspeed squared

so, the slower an airplane is flying, the more it raises the nose.

You will notice this the next time you fly.

At cruising speed, the plane is at around 300 knots (a knot is about 1.16 mile per hour), and it is pretty flat, with an angle of attack in the range of 1-2 degrees. (At altitude, 300 knots corresponds to a much higher ground speed, due to the thinner atmosphere, but that doesn't change the lift relationship.)

When the plane is maneuvering in the approach pattern, its airspeed is more like 150 knots, half of cruise speed. So it has to have roughly 4 times as much angle of attack, anywhere up to about 8 degrees, thus the high nose.

The maximum angle of attack is around 19 degrees, at which the wing stops working. The crew has to stay well below that in order to have reserve lift in case they need to pull up suddenly, like if they hit a downdraft or wind shear, or if they have to turn quickly.

That beautiful photograph of the 747 was taken by another plane flying in formation with it, and for a photo shoot it was probably not travelling at cruising speed. (It's also not very high, unless that's the Himalayas in the background.)