Classical-Mechanics – How is an Object Kept on a Table at Rest?

classical-mechanicsforcesstatics

When there are two bodies A and B lying in contact we can apply Newton's third law which says that the action and the reaction act on different bodies and not on the same body.
That is why two forces don't cancel out each other. Fine till now.
If this is the case then how can an object kept on a table sit at rest? My teacher says that in this case both the forces are acting on the object kept on the table. Aren't the action and the reaction acting on different bodies that is the table and the object. Is he right?

Best Answer

As usual for mechanical statics problems, the entire thing becomes clear if you draw a free body diagram.

enter image description here

Here we have the object (red) sitting on top of a table (blue) which is sitting on the Earth (black curved line). The object experiences two forces

  1. It's weight $W_o$ which is caused by gravitational interaction with the Earth.

  2. A normal force $N_{o,T}$ from the table top. Read the subscript $o,T$ as the force "on the object from the Table".

This probably already answers your question, but let's go on a bit.

The "reaction" force to $W_o$ is an equally strong gravitational pull acting on the Earth itself. The reaction to the normal force is an equally strong normal force pushing down on the table. The table also experiences a normal force $N_{T,o}$ from the object. This is the reaction to $N_{o,T}$ and has equal magnitude to $N_{o,T}$. the table of course also has a weight force $W_T$ and the Earth feels a reaction as shown.

Because the system is static we know that the forces on the object are balanced $$N_{o,T}=W_o \, .$$ We also know that the forces on the table must be balanced $$N_{T,E} = W_T + N_{T,o} \, .$$ As we said, the normal force on the table from the object is a reaction to the normal force on the object from the table, so their mangitudes are equal, $$N_{T,o} = N_{o,T} \, .$$ Therefore $$N_{T,E} = W_T + N_{o,T} = W_T + W_o \, .$$ This is just a careful derivation of the fact that the upward normal force on the table from the Earth must be the sum of the weight of the table and the object! It's just saying that if you pick up the table you feel the weight of both the table and the object on the table.

Related Question