[Physics] How does pressure of a fluid change with area, according to the continuity equation and Bernoulli’s equation

aerodynamicsfluid dynamics

In a nozzle, the exit velocity increases as per continuity equation $Av=const$
as given by Bernoulli equation (incompressible fluid). Pressure is inversely proportional to velocity, so we have lower pressure at the exit of the nozzle. But as per definition of pressure, $P=F/A$, i.e., pressure is inversely proportional to the area which contradicts the above explanation on basis of continuity and Bernoulli equation.

Which is true?
What relation is true for compressible flow?

Best Answer

I disagree with the most voted answer, by CAGT. He says "This area is completely different to the one above", but this means nothing. The equation $p = {F \over A}$ mentioned by the author does hold, and there is no contradiction or paradox in it.

In fact, the equation $p = {F \over A}$ holds not only here but anywhere else in physics. You may write it in any situation, and it will always be true.

Let's begin with a small correction. Your $Av = \text{constant}$ equation is not Bernoulli, but mere conservation of mass. Here's Bernoulli. This is what gives, in your words, "pressure is inversely proportional to velocity." $${p \over \rho} + {v^2 \over 2} + gz = \text{constant}$$

So your problem is with $p = {F \over A}$. Well, there's no problem with it. What is really wrong with your thinking is that you're not paying attention to the equation: the force $F$ changes too.

Let's recap what happens in your situation:

  1. There's a change in cross-sectional area: $A_2 < A_1$
  2. Thanks to conservation of mass, (1) implies $v_2 > v_1$
  3. Thanks to Bernoulli, (2) implies $p_2 < p_1$

Ok, now look at this.

The dark blue rectangle on the left is what we call an element. Like the rest of the flow in the bigger section, it flows with velocity $v_1$. It is delimited left and right by faces with area $A_1$. Note that, since the liquid left and right of it has pressure $p_1$, this element is compressed by forces $F_1 = p_1 A_1$ on each side.

Now to the element on the smaller section, which flows faster. Its cross-sectional area is smaller. The pressure left and right of it is also smaller. As a result, the forces compressing it, $F_2 = p_2 A_2$, are also smaller.

So, $p = {F \over A}$ still holds. Yes, when the situation changes, $A$ is smaller, which by itself would make $p$ bigger. However, as we saw above, then new $F$ is smaller than the old one too, which by itself would make $p$ smaller. The net effect of $p_2 < p_1$ (which we know beforehand from Bernoulli) means, therefore, simply that $F$ has diminished more than $A$ did.