[Physics] How do electrons actually move in a circuit

electric-circuitselectromagnetismelectronsforces

Last year, we were taught about electricity, about how electrons move in a closed circuit. But as our teacher had not taught us about electric fields yet, she gave us a simplified model of motion of electrons in a circuit. (given below)
enter image description here

She told us that, due to chemical reactions taking place inside the dry cell, accumulation of electrons occurs at the -ve terminal and cations at the +ve terminal. When a conductor is connected with the battery, due to accumulation of e at the -ve terminal, there is mutual pushing between electrons, and this causes them to move away from the -ve terminal and towards +ve terminal. Also, cations attract electrons towards the +ve terminal.

Q 1. Is this true that electrons are both attracted and repelled (by cations and other electrons respectively) in an electric circuit?

Q 2. Is this analogy correct? What exactly is happening?

Q 3. Is this (below) a better analogy of electron motion (field lines)? Can electric fields be altered by conductors such as a metal wire? Will most of the field lines be inside of the conductor, Therefore providing a better path for electron flux/flow?
enter image description here

This is not a Duplicate so please don't mark it as one. My real question is, are both analogies correct?

Similar: How does electricity flow in conductor when potential difference is applied?

Very similar : Why does electrical current start to flow?

Best Answer

Your teacher's description is not bad. The phrase about mutual pushing is vague. I'm not sure if he or she means there is pushing to get things started, or pushing to maintain current, or something else. I think it might be fair to say that mutual pushing establishes the charge distribution needed to maintain the current, which I'm about to describe.

Your picture is pretty good, too. Once the current is established, charges accumulate on the surface of the wire in such a way that the surface charge density is positive near the positive battery terminal, negative near the negative battery terminal, and passes through zero somewhere in the middle. The result of this gradient of surface charge is to induce a uniform electric field inside the wire, much as you have drawn. It's this field that applies force to the charge carriers in the wire. You might argue that the charge carriers will accelerate without bound (Newton's second law), but no, each carrier will eventually collide with an impurity or defect and stop (or deflect, or turn back) the carrier, thus limiting the speed. A thermal vibration can do the same. Higher resistance materials have more impurities and defects, and thus lower average carrier speed. Raising the temperature of the material increases the number of thermal vibrations and also raises the resistance. This effect is prominent in a light bulb.