[Physics] Heisenberg uncertainty principle and zero point energy

energyheisenberg-uncertainty-principlequantum mechanics

On my book is written: for a particle in an infinite square well (supposed 1D and large $a$)
\begin{align}
\Delta x\sim a \to& \text{Heisenberg uncertainty principle} \\
\to& \Delta p _\text{min}\sim\frac{h}{2\pi a} \\
\left( E=\frac{p^2}{2m} \right) \to& E_\text{min}\sim\frac{h^2}{8\pi^2a^2m}\,.
\end{align}
However, I'm not sure that the last passage is legal: how is it possible to consider $\Delta p _\text{min}$ and $p$ the same thing? The first is the standard deviation of the aleatory variable $P$, while the second one is the physical value of momentum, so I'd like to understand if there is another way to determine the zero point energy of a system only using the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

Best Answer

One way to think of this is in terms of expectation values. When you say $\Delta p$, what you really mean is the standard deviation of $p$.

$$ \Delta p = \sqrt{\langle p^2\rangle-\langle p \rangle^2} $$ In the case of the ground state, you expect $\langle p \rangle=0$ by symmetry, so you just have $\Delta p = \sqrt{\langle p^2\rangle}$. Then you can consider the expectation value of the energy,

$$ \langle E\rangle = \langle \frac{p^2}{2m}\rangle=\frac{\langle p^2\rangle}{2m}=\frac{(\Delta p)^2}{2m} $$

So far, everything we've written has been exact. But we want to find the minimum possible value for the energy. A moments thought should tell you that the minimum of $\langle E\rangle$ and the minimum of the energy coincide. So you try to find the smallest possible $\langle E\rangle$, and call that $E_{\min}$. That means you want to find the smallest possible $\Delta p$. But of course you know $\Delta x \lesssim a$, so the smallest $\Delta p$ is $\tilde{}\frac{h}{2\pi a}$. Plugging that in gives you $E_\min$.

They key is realizing that if $\langle p\rangle=0$, then the expectation value of $p^2$ is exactly $(\Delta p)^2$. Of course, everything after that is just approximations, but sometimes they work pretty well!