Fluid Dynamics – How to Empty a Bottle Faster by Creating a Swirl

everyday-lifefluid dynamicsvortex

A moment ago, I was emptying bottles filled with water (2 liters) that are on the terrace of my house. As I did so I remembered something I saw on TV a some time ago (I don't remember when or where or exactly what) but I made a move on the horizontal plane as if the bottle drew a circle several times.

To my surprise, after several laps, a vortex was formed and the bottle did empty in half the time than those that are simply put upside down.

I repeated the experiment 20 times to be sure, and always got the same results.

  • Bottle upside down: 20 seconds. (approx)
  • Bottle upside down and rotation to form a vortex: 10 seconds (approx)

Clearly the vortex allows air to enter the bottle faster than in the other case.

I would like to understand what happens in physical terms.

EDIT:

Another interesting fact is that in the first 6/7 seconds just the first liter is gone. And in just two seconds (after the vortex is formed) the remaining water goes fast, very fast.

Best Answer

Assuming you start with a full bottle of water, when you tip the bottle upside down, a 'partial vacuum' (ie below atmospheric pressure) is created at top of the bottle as the water pours out the bottom. Atmospheric air then 'bubbles through' the mouth of the bottle to compensate. This slows down the flow of water through the mouth of the bottle. Each time air is 'bubbling' its way into the mouth, it impedes the flow of water out the bottle.

Once some air gets into the bottle, this air can 'expand' to let some water out of the mouth, until the air pressure inside drops sufficiently low that atmospheric air can 'bubble through' the mouth again. The more air that is inside the bottle, the more this air can 'expand' before bubbling through. That's why the water pours out faster as the bottle gets emptier.

When you swirl the water, the vortex forms a 'gap' in the centre of the mouth of the bottle through which air can flow freely from atmosphere into the bottle. As long as this continuous 'gap' of air is maintained from the mouth of the bottle to the 'top' of the water inside the bottle, there is no 'partial vacuum' above the water, so it doesn't 'bubble' and the water can pour out more evenly & hence faster.

Related Question