[Physics] Effect of initial suction power on siphon performance

fluid dynamicswater

Background

I have a flooded crawl space and I'm using a long hose to siphon the water out.

I do this as follows:

  • One side of the hose is in the crawl space, and the other side down a hill in the garden (lower than the crawl space).
  • I connect a sump pump to the hose in the crawlspace, immerge the pump and start it.
  • While it's underwater, I unscrew the hose from the pump. This results in getting splashed a bit, and if things go well successfully starting the siphon.

Question

Does the initial pumping power (or suction power if done from the other end) matter?

i.e. everything else being equal, will I get a faster siphon if I start the process with a powerful pump than with a weaker pump? Or does that become irrelevant once I disconnect the pump and the siphon starts flowing?

Best Answer

i.e. everything else being equal, will I get a faster siphon if I start the process with a powerful pump than with a weaker pump? Or does that become irrelevant once I disconnect the pump and the siphon starts flowing?

Simply put, only three factors significantly affect flow rate:

  1. Difference in height between inlet and outlet of your siphon. Roughly, the flow speed $v$ ($\mathrm{m/s}$) through the hose is proportional to the square root of the height difference $\Delta h$:

$$v \propto \sqrt{\Delta h}$$

  1. Pipe diameter: that relation is a little more complicated but volumetric throughput benefits greatly from using a smooth, large internal diameter hose or pipe.

  2. Pipe length: volumetric throughput $Q$ is inversely proportional to pipe length $L$:

$$Q \propto \frac1L$$

Initial throughput caused by the pump has no effect once flow has been established and the pump has been switched off: then other laws take over that determine flow rate/throughput.


Edit: with regards to point 3.

Darcy-Weisbach equation for laminar flow:

$$\frac{\Delta p}{L}=f_D \frac {\rho}{2}\frac{v^2}{D}$$ With $f_D=\frac{64}{Re}$ and $Re=\frac{vD}{\eta}$, and $Q=\frac{\pi D^2v}{4}$ then with reworking:

$$\frac{\Delta p}{L}=\frac{128\eta Q}{\pi D^4}$$

Bear in mind that $\Delta p$ is the pressure difference between inlet and outlet of the hose, then all other things being equal:

$$\large{Q \propto \frac{1}{L}}$$

Related Question