Three-Body Problem – Implications for Determinism

determinismnewtonian-mechanicsthree-body-problem

Classical mechanics is famous for its supposed ability to theoretically calculate the state of a system at any given time provided all the necessary initial conditions. I believe this is the definition of determinism.

But a simple system if 3 particles interacting gravitationally fails to admit such a description.
Some people use the arguments that one can still determine the state up to a certain time for any given system, however this is only an approximate prediction leaving even in this limited time window some uncertainty about the system.

EDIT :

This is purely a methematical physics question. Can you formally prove classical mechanics is deterministic from classical mechanics. It's not a question about the universe but about the theory..

Best Answer

But a simple system if 3 particles interacting gravitationally fails to admit such a description.

No it doesn't. Given some set of initial conditions, the gravitational three-body problem can be solved for any time you like, to whatever degree of precision you like. It's true that the result can't be expressed in a neatly-packaged "closed form," but that's more a statement about how we write formulas down than it is a statement about the behavior of the system.

More interesting is the fact that the gravitational three-body problem is generically chaotic, meaning (among other things) that nearby initial conditions diverge from each other exponentially. From a practical point of view, this limits how far in the future we can reliably predict the motion of an observed three-body system. Because our measurements have finite resolution, we can't precisely pin down the true initial state of the system, and two initial conditions which are both compatible with our measurements will eventually evolve to completely different final states. Even if exact measurement of initial conditions were possible, our calculations necessarily have finite precision, which would give us the same problem.

However, this is not the same as non-deterministic evolution. Given exact initial conditions, the evolution of a chaotic system is completely deterministic - it's just that if the model is based on real-world observations, those predictions quickly become relatively meaningless because of uncertainty in the initial conditions and finite numerical precision.

Related Question