Thermodynamics – Does Doubling Density Increase Temperature Recorded on a Thermometer?

energystatistical mechanicstemperaturethermodynamics

At the end of the day what the thermometer is measuring as temperature is energy of the air molecules (which could come in the form of kinetic energy). Now, imagine the following scenario :

  1. Take a box with just one gas molecule (at speed x). It goes and hits the mercury of the thermometer. Thermometer will probably not record its proper temperature.
  2. Now fill the box with a million molecules (at the same speed x), and the thermometer records right some temperature.
  3. Now double the density (but keep the speed of individual air molecules the same). Fill the box with 2 million molecules, but keep the average speed of the molecules the same.

Will it record the same temperature?

My personal intuition is that the temperature recorded should increase, since more molecules are giving energy to that thermometer in the same amount of time.

Best Answer

Assuming an ideal gas, if you are keeping the average speed of the molecules the same then you are holding the temperature of the gas constant. Assuming the container keeps the same volume, by the ideal gas law it must be that the pressure of the gas increases as you add more molecules.

Yes there are more molecules hitting the thermometer, but that also means there are more molecules hitting the thermometer. What I mean by this is that energy can be transferred to the thermometer at a higher rate due to collisions, but collisions at the same increased rate will then transfer that energy from the thermometer back to the gas (and the same vice versa). This is how thermal equilibrium works.

So no, just because you have more gas at the same temperature doesn't mean you will record a higher temperature. More gas will just mean fewer fluctuations about the same temperature.


In addressing points made in the comments, technically the temperature of the thermometer will be somewhere between the starting temperature of the thermometer and the starting temperature of the gas, and the final temperature of the thermometer will approach the starting temperature of the gas as more gas is let in. However, there will come a point where additional gas will make the final temperature indistinguishable from the initial gas temperature, and ideally the thermometer shouldn't influence the temperature of the gas.

Related Question