[Physics] Can facial surgical mask effectively filter particles of smoke pollution

airporous-media

Singapore is having an episode of its regular hazy season because of smoke from forest fires. Some people have been using surgical masks like the the one shown at the bottom of this post, presumably for health reasons.

I know the mask has to stop unwanted particles from getting through. But at the same time, it has to let in enough air to breathe. I understand how it could work to keep people from getting sick – after all, bacteria are much larger than air molecules, so you could have little holes that let air through but keep bacteria out.

But aren't smoke particles too small to be stopped in this way? I think of smoke as a gas (it certainly looks that way, e.g., coming off a candle or a piece of burning incense). Are smoke particles as small as the molecules that I need to breathe in to survive? If they are, how can this mask differentiate between, say, oxygen and smoke?

surgical mask

Best Answer

You are right, these masks are almost useless as a protection against urban aerosols. With swine flu, there was a lot of discussion (example) that even the best masks cannot catch virus particles which are only 100 nm in size. The usual surgical masks are even less effective - they will hardly block anything smaller that 1 micron.

Now, urban aerosols have several size modes: most numerous are just 10-50 nm in size, although most of the mass will be in large 1-10 micron particles (this is the soot/dust that you can see).

The largest particles are blocked by the mask - but they are also filtered by your nose. The smallest particles - below 200 nm - that are considered much more dangerous because they can reach your lungs and even enter the bloodstream. The mask will also not help against nitrogen dioxide - the major component of urban pollution.

Related Question