[Physics] Can a neutron star become a black hole via cooling

astrophysicsblack-holesneutron-starsstellar-physicsthermodynamics

How much does thermal expansion affect neutron stars? Would the loss of temperature cause a neutron star to be more densely packed and thus collapse into a black hole?

Best Answer

No (or at least not much). One of the essential properties of stars that are largely supported by degeneracy pressure, is that this pressure is independent of temperature and that is because although a neutron star may be hot, it has such a small heat capacity, it contains very little thermal energy$^{*}$.

When a neutron star forms, it cools extremely rapidly by the emission of neutrinos, on timescales of seconds. During this phase, the neutron star does contract a little bit (tens of per cent), but by the time its interior has cooled to a billion Kelvin, the interior neutrons are degenerate and the contraction is basically halted. It is possible that a (massive) neutron star could make the transition to a black hole before this point.

If it does not do so, then from there, the neutron star continues to cool (but actually possesses very little thermal energy, despite its high temperature), but this makes almost no difference to its radius.

$^{*}$ In a highly degenerate gas the occupation index of quantum states is unity up the Fermi energy and zero beyond this. In this idealised case, the heat capacity would be zero - no kinetic energy can be extracted from the fermions, since there are no free lower energy states. In practice, and at finite temperatures, there are fermions $\sim kT$ above the Fermi energy that can fall into the few free states at $\sim kT$ below the Fermi energy. However, the fraction of fermions able to do so is only $\sim kT/E_F$, where $E_F$ is the kinetic energy of fermions at the Fermi energy. At typical neutron star densities, this fraction is of order $T/10^{12}\ {\rm K}$, so is very small once neutron stars cool (within seconds) below $10^{10}$ K.

What this means is that the heat capacity is extremely small and that whilst the neutrons in a neutron star contain an enormous reservoir of kinetic energy (thus providing a pressure), almost none of this can be extracted as heat.

Related Question