Conservation of momentum using impulse equations

collisionforceshomework-and-exercisesnewtonian-mechanicsvectors

There is an inclined plane on a frictionless surface. A ball strikes the inclined plane horizontally with velocity $v_o$ and moves vertically after collision with velocity $v$ (see figure) mass of ball=$m$, mass of inclined plane=$M$

figure

Now we have to find the velocity of the ball after collision.
Here's what I did,

figure 2

Now,
$$mv_o-J\sin(\theta) = 0$$
$$J\cos(\theta)=mv$$

Therefore,
$$v=v_o \cot (\theta)$$

The question also asks for the velocity of the inclined plane after collision.

So I did,
$$J\sin (\theta) = Mv'$$
$$v'=mvo/M$$

All my answers are apparently correct according to the book but
the momentum along y-direction remains unconserved even though there is no external force on the system in the y-direction. Why is this so?

Best Answer

Sorry but what I see in the y-direction, the sum of all forces is not zero, so it is not conserved. $$F_M=N\hat y-Mg\hat y=0$$ $$F_m=-mg\hat y$$ where $$\frac{dp}{dt}=\sum F=F_M+F_m=-mg\hat y \neq0$$