Suppose, $G = \mathbb{Z} \ast H$, where $H$ is an arbitrary group. Suppose, $g \in G$ and $g \notin \langle\langle H \rangle \rangle $.
Is $\langle\langle g \rangle \rangle \cap H$ always trivial?
($\ast$ stands for free product, and $\langle \langle \dots \rangle \rangle$ stands for normal closure)
Yesterday, I have asked this question on math.stackexchange.com and was advised to re-ask it there:
Is the intersection of two subgroups, defined below, always trivial? v2.0
Any help will be appreciated.
Best Answer
Your question is related to a famous conjecture:
In fact, a positive answer to your question turns out to be equivalent to the strong Kervaire conjecture:
In the statement, $\exp(g)$ refers to the sum of exponents $\sum\limits_{i=1}^r \epsilon_i$ if you write $g$ as a reduced word $h_1 t^{\epsilon_1} \cdots h_r t^{\epsilon_r} h_{r+1}$ where $h_1, \ldots, h_r \in H$ and $t$ is a fixed generator of $\mathbb{Z}$. Notice that the condition $\exp(g) = 0$ is equivalent to $g \in \langle \langle H \rangle \rangle$, and that the map above is injective precisely when $\langle\! \langle g \rangle\!\rangle \cap H$ is trivial.
You can find relevant references in this document: Presentation of the Kervaire conjecture (notes by A. Ould Houcine).