[Math] Advice on changing topic for thesis problem

advicecareersoft-question

I am starting to find my thesis problem not meaningful nor interesting and too technical. As I learn more mathematics I am finding myself attracted to other topics and only started on my intital problem with my advisor because I could understand it at first.

My problem is a very "good" one, fulfuling many criteria mentioned by mathematicians:

  • It is pitched at exactly the right difficult.
  • It involves learning a big machine
  • It solution leads to further work and questions.

Should I:

  1. Find a new problem? (I'm sure I can't think of such a "good" problem as the one given to me by my advisor.)
  2. Stick with the same problem and only do new problems after graduation?
  3. Anything else?

Best Answer

I would suggest to talk to your advisor. Just tell him exactly what your are telling us:

you think that your thesis problem is not meaningful nor interesting and too technical.

If he displays as an answer some kind of rude behavior, then I think that it's better to change from subject (and from advisor). But my feeling is that you can have a constructive discussion with him. He must first understand what you don't like in your subject. Then he may propose a less technical question or a different angle of attack on the problem. He may explain the relevance of some technics that may appear boring at first sight, but that you will find both enjoyable and powerful as soon as you master it. Just as many mathematical courses don't reveal all their depth in the first sessions, there may be many wonders that await you in the next years of your phd. But some tedious work may be in order before reaching that point.