Why doesn’t Vieta’s formula work for $x^{3}-2x^{2}+ 2x – 1= \frac{15}{x}$

algebra-precalculus

I thought that Vieta's formula worked for all equations, until I encountered this exercise:

What is the sum of all the real solutions $x$ of the equation $x^{3}-2x^{2}+ 2x – 1= \frac{15}{x}$?

After simplifying the equation, I figured that the answer is $2,$ by Vieta's formula. However, by factoring, we find that the sum of the real roots is actually $1.$ Why doesn't Vieta's formula work here to find the sum of roots? In what situations can I use it?

Best Answer

Before using Vieta’s theorem, the equation $$x^3-2x^2+2x-1=\frac{15}{x}$$ must first be rewritten as a polynomial: $$\implies x^4-2x^3+2x^2-x-15=0$$ (notice that $x\neq 0$). The sum of its roots is indeed $-\frac{b}{a}=-\frac{-2}{1}=2$.

Even so, the question asked for the sum of its real roots, whereas Vieta’s formulae give the sum of its complex (including real) roots. That is, the above “sum of its roots” might have contained something like $1+i$ and $1-i,$ and two other roots that cancel each other.

Thus, instead of Vieta's theorem, this exercise requires another technique, such as factoring, as you said, or by using the rational roots theorem.

Related Question