The product of uncountably many copies of the real line is not a $k$-space

general-topology

For the purpose of this question, a $k$-space (or compactly generated space) is a space $X$ whose topology coincides with the final topology with respect to all the inclusions from its compact subspaces. Equivalently, a set $U\subseteq X$ is open iff the intersection $U\cap C$ is open in $C$ for every compact subspace $C$ of $X$.

Willard, exercise 43H (part 2) says:

The product of uncountably many copies of $\mathbb R$ is not a $k$-space.

So let $I$ be some uncountable index set. The set $\omega=\{0,1,2,…\}$ is closed in $\mathbb R$, so $\omega^I$ is closed in $\mathbb R^I$. Since any closed subspace of $k$-space is a $k$-space, it is sufficient to show:

Give $\omega$ the discrete topology. The product of uncountably many copies of $\omega$ is not a $k$-space.

Proof (incomplete): We have to show that $X=\omega^I$ with the product topology is not a $k$-space. Following the hint in Willard, take $T=\bigcup_{n=1}^\infty T_n\subseteq X$ where $T_n$ is the set of points $x$ such that $x_i=0$ for at most $n$ coordinates and $x_i=n$ for all the other coordinates. The claim is that $T$ is not closed, but is $k$-closed.

(1) $T$ is not closed: The point $\mathbf{0}\in X$ with all coordinate equal to $0$ is in $\overline T$, because every basic nbhd of it consists of all points that are zero on some finite set $J\subseteq I$, and that will contain some point in $T_n$ for $n$ large enough.

No other point outside of $T$ is in $\overline T$. That is easy to check. For example if a point $x$ has at least two non-zero values $x_i=n$ and $x_j=m$, the nbhd of $x$ defined by these conditions is disjoint from $T$. And similarly if almost all values $x_i$ are equal to $n$, but $x$ has more than $n$ zeros. So $\overline T=T\cup\{\mathbf 0\}$.

(2) $T$ is $k$-closed: We have to show that given any compact $C\subseteq X$, the set $T\cap C$ is closed in $C$.

How to show this last part?

Best Answer

Borrowing some ideas from R. Brown, Ten topologies for $X\times Y$, Quarterly J. Math., 14(1) (1963), pp. 303-319, here is a solution for part (2) showing that $T$ is $k$-closed.

Given a compact set $C$ in $X$, we have to show that $T\cap C$ is closed in $C$. Since $X$ is Hausdorff, $C$ is closed in $X$ and it is equivalent to show that $T\cap C$ is closed in $X$.

For each $i\in I$, the projection $\pi_i(C)$ of $C$ onto the $i$-th component is compact, so there is some integer $n$ such that $\pi_i(C)\subseteq [0,n]$. For each $n$, let $I_n=\{i\in I:\pi_i(C)\subseteq [0,n]\}$. Then $I$ is the countable union of the $I_n$ for $n=1,2,\dots$. Since $I$ is uncountable, at least one these sets, say $I_m$, is infinite. (One could even choose an uncountable one, but infinite is all we need.) Now, as shown in part (1), $\overline T=T\cup\{\mathbf 0\}$. So to show that $T\cap C$ is closed in $X$, it is enough to find a nbhd of $\mathbf 0$ that is disjoint from $T\cap C$. Since $I_m$ is infinite, we can choose a subset $J\subseteq I_m$ with $m+1$ elements. The nbhd of $\mathbf 0$ consisting of those points that are $0$ at elements of $J$ is disjoint from $T\cap C$ by construction. This completes the proof.