Show that this set is homeomorphic to $S^1\times{}S^1$

general-topology

Let $X=\{((b+a\cos(\theta))\sin(\phi),(b+a\cos(\theta))\cos(\phi),a\sin(\theta))\in{}\mathbb{R}^3|\theta,\phi\in{}[0,2\pi)\}$ with $0<a<b$.

I am trying to show $X\simeq {}S^1\times{}S^1$.

I understand that if we consider the unit square, with the bottom and top sides identified with identified endpoints, same with the left and right sides, we can embed this in $\mathbb{R}^3$ to get the torus. But can I use this with $X$ to show what I am after?

Best Answer

Let $R = [0,2\pi] \times [0,2\pi]$. The map $p : [0,2\pi] \to S^1, p(t) = e^{it}$, is a quotient map which identifies the two points $0, 2\pi \in [0,2\pi]$ to a single point in $S^1$.

The map $q = p \times p : R \to T = S^1 \times S^1$ is a quotient map. It identifies $(\theta,0)$ with $(\theta,2\pi)$ and $(0,\phi) $ with $(2\pi,\phi)$ as desribed in your question.

Define $$f : R \to \mathbb R^3, f(\theta,\phi) = ((b+a\cos \theta)\sin \phi,(b+a\cos \theta)\cos \phi,a\sin \theta) .$$ $f(\theta,\phi) = f(\theta',\phi')$ means that

  1. $(b+a\cos \theta)\sin \phi = (b+a\cos \theta')\sin \phi'$

  2. $(b+a\cos \theta)\cos \phi = (b+a\cos \theta')\cos \phi'$

  3. $a\sin \theta = a\sin \theta'$, i.e. $\sin \theta = \sin \theta'$.

Squaring 1. and 2. and adding yields

  1. $(b+a\cos \theta)^2 = (b+a\cos \theta')^2$

Since $0 < a < b$, both $b+a\cos \theta, b+a\cos \theta'$ are positive and we conclude

  1. $b+a\cos \theta = b+a\cos \theta'$, i.e. $cos \theta = \cos \theta'$.

Inserting 5. in 1. and 2. gives us

  1. $\sin \phi = \sin \phi'$

  2. $\cos \phi = \cos \phi'$

We have $\theta, \theta' \in [0,2\pi]$, hence 3. and 5. show that either $\theta = \theta'$ or that one of $\theta, \theta'$ is $0$ and the other is $2\pi$. Similarly, 6. and 7. show that $\phi = \phi'$ or that one of $\phi, \phi'$ is $0$ and the other is $2\pi$.

This shows that $f(\theta,\phi) = f(\theta',\phi')$ if and only if $q(\theta,\phi) = q(\theta',\phi')$. By the universal property of the quotient $f$ induces a unique injective map $f' : T \to \mathbb R^3$ such that $f' q = f$. Since $T$ is compact and $f(R)$ is Hausdorff, we see that $f' : T \to f(R)$ is a homeomorphism. But clearly $$f(R) = f([0,2\pi) \times [0,2\pi)). $$