Real, Complex, Quaternionic and Octonionic Projective spaces

algebraic-topologydifferential-geometrylie-groupsoctonionsquaternions

Do Octonionic Projective spaces exist or defined similar to $\Bbb RP^n$, $\Bbb CP^n$, $\Bbb HP^n$? If so, are they symmetric spaces?

I am asking this question because I've never seen Octonionic Projective spaces as examples of the Compact Rank One Symmetric Spaces or the manifolds of positive sectional curvature except its 2-dimensional case i.e. Cayley plane $\Bbb OP^2$ (or $\Bbb{Ca}P^2$). What can be say about $\Bbb OP^n$ (or $\Bbb{Ca}P^n$)?


Update: Please give a proof or a reference for non-existence of Octonionic Projective spaces for $n\geq 3$.

Related question: Quaternion Projective Space $\mathbb HP^n$ and Octonionic Projective Space $\mathbb OP^n$

Best Answer

Paul is right (and I upvoted him!) that the usual definition of projective spaces requires multiplication to be associative.

However, this seems to be counter to the fact that $\mathbb{O}P^1$ and $\mathbb{O}P^2$ exist. I have heard the explanation that "the octionions are associative enough" to support the existence of these two spaces, but honestly, I've never understood it. Instead, I understand projective spaces more geometrically and topologically.

Geometrically: Each projective space $\mathbb{K}P^n$ with $\mathbb{K}\in\{\mathbb{R}, \mathbb{C}, \mathbb{H}\}$ has a canonical Riemannian metric, called the Fubini-Study metric.

With regards to this metric, the manifolds are homogeneous (better, they are symmetric spaces), with sectional curvatures lying between $1$ and $4$. In addition, for any $p\in \mathbb{K}P^n$, the cut locus is a copy of $\mathbb{K}P^{n-1}$ and the preimage of a point in $\mathbb{K}P^{n-1}$ in the unit sphere in $T_p \mathbb{K}P^n$ gives the expected Hopf fibration.

One can easily generalize this to what $\mathbb{O}P^n$ should be. It should be a symmetric space with curvature between $1$ and $4$, and with the cut locus working as expected. Of course, when $n=1$, $\mathbb{O}P^1\cong S^8$ fits kind of trivially. When $n=2$, there is such an example: $F_4/Spin(9)$ with normal homogeneous metric meets all the criteria.

However, we've classified symmetric spaces, and we've classified spaces with curvature between $1$ and $4$. From either of these classifications, there is no $\mathbb{O}P^n$ for $n > 2$.

Topologically: The cohomology ring of $\mathbb{K}P^n$ for $\mathbb{K}\in \{\mathbb{C},\mathbb{H}\}$ is a truncated polynomial algebra: $H^\ast(\mathbb{K}P^n;\mathbb{Z})\cong \mathbb{Z}[\alpha]/\alpha^{n+1}$ where $|\alpha| = \dim_{\mathbb{R}} \mathbb{K}$. One could reasonably define a "topological projective space" to be a manifold having a truncated polynomial ring as it's cohomology ring. This is not done, because there are essentially no other examples.

In Hatcher's Algebraic topology book, Theorem 4L.9 gives that $|\alpha|$ must be a power of $2$. Then, Corollary 4L.10 proves that there is no $\mathbb{O}P^n$ for $n\geq 3$.

Further, the ring $\mathbb{Z}[\alpha]/\alpha^3$ for $|\alpha| = 2^k$, $k\geq 4$ cannot arise by Adam's solution to the Hopf invariant one problem.

Related Question