I'm trying to transform this logical statement $\neg\forall x\exists y(P(x, y)\lor Q(x, y))$ to have
negation before predicates and I'm asking for a little explanation. Are these steps
I performed earlier correct or am I wrong, and how to do that the proper way?
$\neg\forall x\exists y(P(x, y)\lor Q(x, y))$
My steps:
-
$\exists x\neg(\exists y(P(x, y)\lor Q(x, y)))$
-
$\exists x\forall y\neg(P(x, y)\lor Q(x, y))$
-
$\exists x\forall y(\neg P(x, y)\land\neg Q(x, y))$
So this is the final statement I get :
$$\exists x\forall y(\neg P(x, y)\land\neg Q(x, y))$$
Is this correct? You guys are the best 🙂
Best Answer
Yes, you seem to have a clear understanding of bringing the negation into what is being quantified.
For you're first step, you could have started with $$\exists x \lnot\exists y\Big((P(x, y) \lor Q(x, y)\Big).$$
But either way, the steps you demonstrate are correct.