Prove that in a sequence of chained subsets, the intersection is finite and nonempty

elementary-set-theoryreal-analysis

The heading is merely a simplified version. Currently, I am reading Understanding Analysis and working on the preliminaries. The question is:

If $A_1 \supseteq A_2 \supseteq A_3 \supseteq A_4\cdots$ are all finite, nonempty sets of real numbers, then the intersection $\bigcap_{n=1}^\infty A_n$ is finite and nonempty.

The book at this point has not formally defined finite. In addition, the only hint, in my opinion, offered by the book is the following question,

If $A_1 \supseteq A_2 \supseteq A_3 \supseteq A_4\cdots$ are all sets containing an infinite number of elements, then the intersection $\bigcap_{n=1}^\infty A_n$ is infinite as well.

With this question and an aforementioned example, I can solve this problem by defining the set $A_i = \{i,i+1,i+2\dots\}\subseteq N$ and a proof by contradiction.

However, when it comes to $A_i$ containing finite elements, I just don't now how to

  1. Prove by definition
  2. Understand the intuition behind can't find a counter example like the infinite version

Best Answer

One way is to notice that a decreasing sequence of positive integers, in this case the cardinalities of the sets $A_k$, must eventually be constant. For $k\in\Bbb Z^+$ let $n_k=|A_k|$, the number of elements in $A_k$; $n_k$ is a positive integer. Let $N=\{n_k:k\in\Bbb Z^+\}$; $N$ is a non-empty set of positive integers, so it has a smallest element $m$. Let $\ell\in\Bbb Z^+$ be such that $n_\ell=m$.

$A_{\ell+1}\subseteq A_\ell$, so $n_{\ell+1}\le n_\ell=m$. But $m=\min N$, so $n_{\ell+1}\ge m$, and therefore $n_{\ell+1}=m$. Thus, $A_{\ell+1}\subseteq A_\ell$ and $|A_{\ell+1}|=|A_\ell|$ , so $A_{\ell+1}=A_\ell$. You can use this idea to prove by induction that $A_k=A_\ell$ for every $k\ge\ell$. Then you’re almost done. $A_k\supseteq A_\ell$ for $k=1,\ldots,\ell$, and $A_k=A_\ell$ for $k>\ell$, so

$$\bigcap_{k\ge 1}A_k=\bigcap_{k=1}^\ell A_k\cap\bigcap_{k>\ell}A_k=A_\ell\cap A_\ell=A_\ell\,.$$

Related Question