Periodic solutions of a planar ODE

ordinary differential equations

Linearizing the equation of the two body problem at a circular solution I came accross the following planar second order system of differential equations
$$
\begin{cases}
2\frac{1}{\omega^2} \ddot{u}=3u\cos2\omega t+3v\sin2\omega t+u\\
2\frac{1}{\omega^2}\ddot{v}=3u\sin2\omega t-3v\cos2\omega t+v
\end{cases}
$$

It is easy to see that $(u,v)=(-\sin\omega t,\cos\omega t)$ is a $\frac{2\pi}{\omega}$-periodic solution. I'm wondering if there are other independent ones.
Do you have any suggestion to find them?

Best Answer

If we define $\eta = u + i v$, then the set of equations can be rewritten as $$ 0 = - \frac{2}{\omega^2} \ddot{\eta} + 3 e^{2 i \omega t} \bar{\eta} + \eta. $$ If $\eta$ is periodic with period $2 \pi/\omega$, then it will be expressible as a power series of the form $$ \eta = \sum_{m = - \infty}^\infty a_m e^{i m \omega t}. $$ Putting this ansatz into the ODE and manipulating the series appropriately, we find that if $\eta$ is of this form and satisfies the above ODE, then we must have $$ (1 + 2 m^2) a_m + 3 a^*_{2-m} = 0 $$ for all $m$.

This "recursion" relation relates the coefficients $a_m$ in pairs; it relates $a_1$ to itself, $a_0$ to $a_2$, $a_{-1}$ to $a_3$, and so forth. Note that all of these pairs of coefficients are determined independently: the value of $\{a_0, a_2\}$ are unaffected by the values of $\{a_{-1}, a_3\}$ or any other pair. Moreover, if we set $m \to 2-m$ in the above recursion relation and conjugate it, we obtain $$ (1 + 2(2-m)^2) a^*_{2-m} + 3 a_m = 0, $$ and combining the above two equations yields $$ \left[ (1 + 2m^2) (1 + 2(2-m)^2) - 9 \right] a_m = 0 $$ for all $m$. Assuming we want $a_m \neq 0$, this implies the quantity in brackets must vanish. But the only roots of this polynomial are $m = 0, 1, 2$ (with 1 a double root). Thus, the only $a_m$ coefficients that can be non-zero are $a_0$, $a_1$, and $a_2$. Taking these cases separately:

  • For $a_1 \neq 0$, the recursion relation is $3 a_1 + 3 a^*_1 = 0$, which implies that $a_1$ is pure imaginary. Thus, the solution is $\eta = A i e^{i \omega t}$ for $A \in \mathbb{R}$, which (taking the real and imaginary parts) yields the solution you found: $u(t) = - A \sin(\omega t)$, $v(t) = A \cos (\omega t)$.

  • For the pair $\{a_0, a_2\}$, we have $$a_0 = - 3 a_2^*.$$ Thus, we have a general solution of the form $$ \eta(t) = a_0 - \frac{1}{3} a_0^* e^{2 i \omega t} $$ for an arbitrary complex number $a_0$. Expressing this in terms of two real coefficients $a_0 = A + iB$, the solution then becomes $$ u(t) = A\left( 1 - \frac{1}{3} \cos (2 \omega t)\right) - \frac{B}{3} \sin (2 \omega t), \\ v(t) = B\left( 1 + \frac{1}{3} \cos (2 \omega t) \right) - \frac{A}{3} \sin (2 \omega t). \\ $$
    The solutions found by Robert Israel correspond to $B = -3, A = 0$ and $A = -3, B = 0$ respectively.

These three independent solutions, and linear combinations thereof, are the only possible solutions with a period of $2\pi/\omega$.

Related Question