Munkres’ Topology – Theorem 15.2

general-topology

Theorem 15.2 of Topology by Munkres states:

The collection
$$\mathcal{S} = \{\pi_1^{-1}(U)|U \text{ open in X}\} \cup \{\pi_2^{-1}(V)|V \text{ open in Y}\}$$
is a subbasis for the product topology on $X \times Y$.

He defined $\pi_1:X \times Y \rightarrow X$ by $\pi_1(x,y)=x$ and similarly $\pi_2: X \times Y \rightarrow Y$ by $\pi_2(x,y)=y.$

It seems to be there is no restriction on the set from $X \times Y$ that is being mapped. So for an example, consider the set $X = \{1,2\}$ and $Y=\{3,4\}$ with topologies $\mathcal{T}_X = \{\phi,\{1\}, \{1,2\}\}$ and $\mathcal{T}_Y = \{\phi, \{3\}, \{3,4\}\}$.

Consider $\{2\} \times \{4\} = \{(2,4)\}$. The mapping $\pi_1(2,4)=2$ and $\pi_2(2,4)=4$. For one thing, these mappings do not give sets, rather an element of $X$ or $Y$. Shouldn't they be sets? Since only sets like $\{2\}$ or $\{4\}$ can be open but not an element like $2$ and $4$.

Moreover, $\{2\}$ and $\{4\}$ are not open in their respective topologies. So their pre-image would just be the empty set, and an empty set cannot be a subbasis which means I am applying this theorem wrong. I would like to know where am I going wrong? When he defines the mapping $\pi_1:X \times Y \rightarrow X$ does he mean the set $X \times Y$ or any subset of $X \times Y$?

Also, could you please provide an example where the subbasis generated by this theorem is not a basis? It is appreciated if the example is for finite sets.

Best Answer

Note first that your post (in my version of Munkres this is correct) contains a typo. $\mathcal{S}$ is a subbasis of $X \times Y$ and not of $X$.

In your case: $$\{\pi_1^{-1}(U): U \in \tau_X\}= \{\pi_1^{-1}(\emptyset),\pi_1^{-1}(\{1\}), \pi_1^{-1}(\{1,2\})\}= \{\emptyset, \{1\}\times Y, X \times Y\}$$ Similarly

$$\{\pi_2^{-1}(U): U \in \tau_X\}= \{\pi_2^{-1}(\emptyset),\pi_2^{-1}(\{1\}), \pi_2^{-1}(\{1,2\})\}= \{\emptyset, X\times \{3\}, X \times Y\}$$

Thus, $$\mathcal{S}= \{\emptyset, X \times Y, \{1\}\times Y, X\times \{3\}\}$$ $$=\{\emptyset, \{(1,3),(1,4),(2,3),(2,4)\}, \{(1,3),(1,4)\}, \{(1,3),(2,3)\}\}$$ is a subbasis of $X \times Y$.

It is not a basis, because a basis must contain $\{(1,3)\}= \{1\}\times \{3\}$.