[Math] Would the Riemann Hypothesis being false affect how frequently primes occur in the number system

number theoryriemann-hypothesisriemann-zeta

I want to know that if Riemann hypothesis is false (big assumption) would that lead to any effect in how frequently primes occur . Well I got this half cooked information from here: http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/21561457#21561457

And I want to get a bit more information on what was said over there.

By the way primes occur I mean that will the primes start occurring more frequently. If they start occurring more frequently, can we find out by how much? Then we might be able to relate this to the new bound which has been found between primes. That might give us a connection between the twin prime conjecture and the Riemann hypothesis.

Best Answer

The distribution of primes is not going to change. No matter what we discover about the Riemann hypothesis or any other area of math, the distribution of primes will not change.

The Riemann hypothesis implies a bound on the error term in the prime number theorem. Specifically, it implies that $\pi(x)=\frac x{\log x}+O(\sqrt x\log x)$. If the Riemann hypothesis is shown not to be true, then we will not know that this result is true. (I believe, though I may be wrong, that the result is implied by but not equivalent to the RH; correct me if I'm wrong.)

Now, any theoretical proof that the RH is false (or true) would almost certainly involve theory which would cast further light on the distribution of the primes in some regard which might be more valuable than the disproof (or proof) of the RH itself. A discovery of a zero not on the critical line would of course be less helpful in this regard.

In either case, it is unlikely that the RH has any direct connection to the twin prime conjecture, since twin primes occur with frequency at most $\frac 1{\log x}$ in the primes (Brun's theorem), so a bound on the error term in the prime number theorem is probably too specific a result to have much effect. The twin prime conjecture is more closely related to the occurrence of primes in polynomials, and so to conjectures such as Schinzel's Hypothesis H or the Bateman-Horn conjecture (each of which imply the twin prime conjecture) or Bunyakovsky's conjecture (a weaker version of the above two which does not).

Related Question