[Math] Which area is larger, the blue area, or the white area

areaeuclidean-geometrygeometry

In the square below, two semicircles are overlapping in a symmetrical pattern. Which is greater: the area shaded blue or the area shaded white?

enter image description here

My Solution

Let the length of each side of the square be $2r$.
The area of the square is $4r^2$.

The two semi-circles have equal area.
Area of one semi-circle = $\frac{{\pi}r^2}{2}$.
${\times}2 = {\pi}r^2$

White area = ${\pi}r^2 – $ area of the intersection of the two circles.

Let the area of the intersection of the two circles be $t$.
White area = ${\pi}r^2 – t$.

The segments that make up $t$ are identical.
$t$ = area of segment ${\times}2$.

Area of segment = Area of sector – Area of triangle.
Angle of sector = $90^{\circ}$ (The circles both have radius $r$, and the outer shape is a square.
Angle of sector $ = \frac{1}{4} * {\pi}r^2$.
Area of triangle $ = \frac{1}{2} * r^2$.
Area of segment $ = \frac{{\pi}r^2 – 2r^2}{4}$.
$t = 2 {\times} \frac{{\pi}r^2 – 2r^2}{4}$.
$t = \frac{{\pi}r^2 – 2r^2}{2}$.

White area $ = {\pi}r^2 – \frac{{\pi}r^2 – 2r^2}{2}$.
White area $ = \frac{2{\pi}r^2 – {\pi}r^2 + 2r^2}{2}$.
White area $ = \frac{{\pi}r^2 + 2r^2}{2}$.

Blue area = $r^2\left(4 – \frac{{\pi} + 2}{2}\right)$.
Blue area = $r^2\left(\frac{8 – ({\pi} + 2)}{2}\right)$.
Blue area = $r^2\left(\frac{6 – {\pi}}{2}\right)$.

If White area $-$ Blue area $ \gt 0$, then the White area is larger.

$$r^2\left(\frac{{\pi}+2 – (6 – {\pi}}{2}\right)$$
$$r^2\left(\frac{2{\pi} – 4}{2}\right)$$
$$r^2(\pi – 2)$$

$\therefore$ the white area is larger.

My answer was wrong.

What is the error in my solution?

The provided solution:

The provided solution

Best Answer

If you just divide the lower left part of the blue area and move each part $90$ degree up to join them to the main blue part, then the area of the new blue shape will be equal to the white part. enter image description here