Vector Spaces – Difference Between Zero Scalar and Zero Vector

definitionsoft-questionvector-spacesvectors

Zero vector has zero value in the given vector space. So, it is different from zero scalar. Zero vector is additive identity of the given vector space whereas zero scalar is not. I do understand this academic distinction. But I still have following $2$ doubts.

(i) In one dimensional space, is zero scalar same as to zero vector?

According to me – NO. In $1D$ space, the vectors may be expressed in real number notation (instead of matrix notation) where absolute value of real number indicates magnitude and sign indicated direction. Then, we are using 'real number notation' to represent not a real number, but a vector in $1D$. What we represent is not real number. So, a zero vector in $1D$ space is indeed expressed as $0$ in 'real number notation'. However it is not representing the real number zero (which is member of set of real numbers) but representing zero vector (which is a member of vectors in 1D space). So, in $1D$ space, a zero vector may be represented by number $0$. But it is not the real number $0$.

Analogy -: A directed segment represents a vector. It is not a vector.

(ii) Is zero speed same as zero velocity? In general, if we define a scalar quantity $Q_1$ which is magnitude of a vector quantity $Q_2$, then is zero $Q_1$ same as zero $Q_2$?

According to me – NO. When speed is zero, then the velocity is zero and vice-versa. However, zero speed is not equal to zero velocity.

Best Answer

For question 1) the answer is "usually no". For example, let $n$ be a positive integer greater than $1$ and let $V$ be a one dimensional subspace of $\mathbb R^n$. The zero vector in $V$ is certainly not the scalar $0$. The reason I say "usually" no is that if you view $\mathbb R$ as a vector space over $\mathbb R$, then the zero vector happens to be equal to the zero scalar. You could cook up some other examples like that.

For question 2, speed is a scalar and velocity is a vector. If an object has speed $0$, then its velocity is the zero vector, but its speed is not equal to its velocity. (They could not be equal because they are not even the same type of mathematical object.)

To be more concrete, let's say that I introduce a coordinate system in my lab and measure that my speed (in meters/sec) is the number $0$. Then my velocity (in meters / sec) is $(0,0,0)$. And $0 \neq (0,0,0)$.

Here's another way to make the same point. Suppose that a particle's position at time $t$ is $f(t)$, where $f:\mathbb (a,b) \to \mathbb R^3$ is a differentiable function. The particle's velocity at time $t_0$ is $f'(t_0)$, and the particle's speed at time $t_0$ is $\| f'(t_0)\|$. Suppose that the particle's speed at time $t_0$ is the number $0$. Then the particle's velocity at time $t_0$ is $f'(t_0) = (0,0,0)$. And again, $0 \neq (0,0,0)$.

Related Question