[Math] Range of trigonometric functions

trigonometry

I would like to know if there is a simple approach to find the range of functions in the form:
$$\sin x\sin2x$$
$$\cos x\cos3x$$
$$\sin 2x\cos 4x$$

For example, finding the range of a function in the form:
$$a\cos\theta + b\sin\theta$$ is simple (the minimum value is $-\sqrt{a^2 + b^2}$ while the maximum value is $\sqrt{a^2 + b^2}$.

Best Answer

It's more interesting when it is not the obvious upper bound $1$. I will take the example $\sin 3x \cos 5 x$. It does not reach the value $1$, so we have some work to do. Let's find an implicit equation for the curve $C \colon \{(\sin(3t), \cos (5t))\ \mid \ t\in [0, 2 \pi]\}$ ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lissajous_curve). Skipping some details, it is the curve with equation $$-1 + 25 x^2 - 200 x^4 + 560 x^6 - 640 x^8 + 256 x^{10} + 9 y^2 - 24 y^4 + 16 y^6=0$$

It has to do with the Chebyshev polynomials. In fact, a point $(x,y)$ in $\mathbb{R}^2$ is of the form $(\sin (3t), \cos(5t))$ if and only if $1 = P(x) + Q(y)$ where $P(\sin( \alpha))= \sin^2 (5 \alpha)$ and $Q(\cos(\beta)) = \cos^2(3 \beta)$. (the only if is clear, since $\sin^2(15 t) + \cos^2(15 t) = 1$). So it is not that hard to get the implicit form for the curve $C$.

So now we need to find

$$\max x y \ \text{ where }\ -1 + 25 x^2 - 200 x^4 + 560 x^6 - 640 x^8 + 256 x^{10} + 9 y^2 - 24 y^4 + 16 y^6=0$$

We omit the calculations using Lagrange multipliers. It turns out that the maximum $M$ is the largest root of the equation $$1073741824\, t^8-1644167168\, t^6+656998400\, t^4-52537500 \,t^2+84375=0$$ $M= 0.96410...$

Well, at least setting the Lagrange multiplier problem in general is not that hard. Solving it is a different thing.

The Lissajous curve $C$

It is not clear to me whether a general easy formula for this maximum exists for general $m$, $n$ for $\max \sin(m t) \cos (n t )$. Maybe a general method, not a general formula that is easy to apply.

Alternatively one writes

$$\sin 3t \cos 5 t = \frac{1}{2}( \sin 8t - \sin 2t)$$

Reduce to an equivalent problem: maximize $ \sin 4u - \sin u$. Even this one is not straightforward. Certainly the derivative is easy to calculate but the maximal value is again the solution of an equation of degree $8$. Perhaps the advantage is that one can find the solution from the graphs of $\sin u$, $\sin 4u$. enter image description here

$\bf{Added:}$. If one looks for the maximum value of $\sin mt \cos nt$, it's enough to consider the case $m,n$ relatively prime. Then, even it the maximal value is not $1$, it will get closer to one with the increase of $\max (m,n)$. It is intuitive since the Lissajous curves tend to fill up the square. It would be interesting to investigate how close to $1$ one gets as $\max(m,n) \to \infty$. It appears that number theory, more precisely - rational approximation, appears.

Related Question