What are the proper divisors of 1?
I understand proper divisors do not include the number itself, but is 1 an exception or does it have no proper divisors?
[Math] Proper divisors of 1
definitiondivisibilityelementary-number-theorynumber theory
Related Question
- [Math] Why does the number of divisors of a superior highly composite number is always a highly composite number up to 720720 ? (the only exception is 120)
- Does there exist a composite, deficient, odd number that is divisible by the sum of its proper factors
- “Divisors” vs “factors”
- Question on sums of products of divisors
Best Answer
It depends on the structure and/or your definition of proper divisor.
If you say that a divisor $d$ of $b$ is proper if $d \neq b$, then the proper divisors of $1$ are exactly the invertible elements/units of the ambient structure except $1$. That is none for $\mathbb{N}$, $-1$ for $\mathbb{Z}$, $-1,i,i$ for $\mathbb{Z}[i]$ and so on.
If you say that a divisor $d$ of $b$ is proper if $dc=b$ with a non-invertible $c$, that is $d$ is not associated to $b$, then $1$ has no proper divisors.
Personally, I would go for the second definition.